Surgeons typically lack empathy. It is what allows them to cut into people. I could never do that job.
The guy is probably an excellent scientist because he's a sociopath. The article doesn't address that fact.
There's a lot of disparate things in these two sentences:
1. It's othering: so what? Everyone is unique and different, and any time you talk about those differences it's othering. If you view othering as a problem, then literally any conversation about differences between people is problematic.
2. Blamey? What is the article blaming him for, exactly?
3. I don't think the article assumes this is all downside. I also don't think you can ignore the fact that psychopathy has very serious downsides.
4. Psychopathy is absolutely something he needs to compensate for in order to be a prosocial member of society. The fact that he seems willing and able to compensate is amazing and admirable.
> Surgeons typically lack empathy. It is what allows them to cut into people. I could never do that job.
I'd love to see where you get your information that surgeons typically lack empathy. Maybe some do, but many don't and function just fine. I personally don't lack empathy, but I think I could cut someone open easily if it were to help them. I'm not a psychopath, I just have a strong sense of the difference between hurt and harm: I can hurt someone if it helps them rather than harming them.
> The guy is probably an excellent scientist because he's a sociopath. The article doesn't address that fact.
The article probably doesn't address that "fact" because there's very little to support a causal link.
The fit of rage at the end is not necessarily associated with sociopathy. That kind of lack of control is common with things like fetal alcohol syndrome and head injury syndromes.
I raised a sociopath. He's 30 now. We're close and get along well. My other son is not a sociopath, but has a violent temper. Neither has a criminal record and I find articles like the one under discussion rather unsophisticated and annoying.
My sons are okay in part because I never expected them to be born knowing things like "Lying is bad." One child went through a lying stage. The other did not. I successfully broke him of lying because I viewed it as "Wow, you dumb kid who has no idea how social stuff works" rather than "You evil badly behaved child doing bad things on purpose."