News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Music now has 38M paid members by RileyJames on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:51PM (#16581334)
I haven't used Apple music, but I feel Spotify also falls down in the UI. There seem to be plenty of pitfalls where the best of both worlds could be provided, yet aren't.

Basics like, why only show the top 5 popular songs from an artist? with no option to "view all songs based on popularity"

If I can't recall a song name from an artist, I then need to start going through individual albums to find it... Or if I've over played the top 5 songs, and just quickly want to throw something from say, the top 20. No dice.

Alternatively, if I go into "my library" and select an artist, I now see ONLY those songs I've saved. With no option to view the rest of what they have to offer. Likewise for an album (only songs I've saved on that album).

And WHY can't I scroll backwards through the songs I've most recently played WITHOUT changing the current song? Seriously? Has a spotify staff member never been in a situation where their friend has asked, "hey what was that song two songs ago?"

These seems like pretty basic UI navigation options that should be easy to access.

Re:Apple Music now has 38M paid members by b1daly on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @12:57AM (#16582456)
The Spotify interface relies heavily on the “...” option. This menu always provides the option to go to album, artist, like the track, and share.

This suboptimal in one major way, which is that this three dot link is hard to target!