Re:Scientist's Firing After 36 Years Fuels 'PC' Debate at UCLA
by natrius on Friday September 03, 2010 @02:26AM
(#1658813)
It's hard to find a widely accepted news source with as much of an agenda as Fox has. Fox News is an overtly partisan observer. It's reasonable to ask for further corroboration.
Re:Scientist's Firing After 36 Years Fuels 'PC' Debate at UCLA
by lzw on Thursday September 02, 2010 @10:40PM
(#1658444)
Science is not politically correct, as we've seen in the whole Global Warming fiasco. Ever since the government took over the universities, we've seen this increasing more and more.
I say this as scientist who used to work for a major university in a major national lab. Certain outcomes are not acceptable, even if they are scientifically correct.
Re:Scientist's Firing After 36 Years Fuels 'PC' Debate at UCLA
by jseliger on Friday September 03, 2010 @12:45AM
(#1658651)
Science is not politically correct, as we've seen in the whole Global Warming fiasco.
Neither are politics, much of the time, and the problem with linking to an article from Fox is the network's slant. I'm not the only person to notice this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1658518 .
Until someone else picks this up and/or tries to see if it's actually true, it doesn't mean jack.
Re:Scientist's Firing After 36 Years Fuels 'PC' Debate at UCLA
by mturmon on Friday September 03, 2010 @01:05AM
(#1658675)
Since when did "the government" take over "the universities"? What department of "the government" gives orders to university professors? DARPA? NOAA?
I guess this is a transnational agreement, because faculty move back and forth across the oceans, and their opinions don't change much. "The government" must be a lot more well-organized than I'd suspected.
Re:Scientist's Firing After 36 Years Fuels 'PC' Debate at UCLA
by noblethrasher on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:37AM
(#1658915)
Admittedly I've never verified this but one of my history professors said that the department of education (under the Bush administration) requested that the instructors present a more pro-American narrative (or rather complained of a very anti-American bias in recent scholarship).
(Obviously you should take this hearsay anecdote with the proverbial minimal quantity of sodium chloride but I'll try to verify it with some other professors in the department.)
Re:Scientist's Firing After 36 Years Fuels 'PC' Debate at UCLA
by msie on Friday September 03, 2010 @12:32AM
(#1658639)
In 2003 he wrote a study, published in the British Medical Journal, in which he found no causal relationship between secondhand smoke and tobacco-related death – a conclusion that drew fire both because it was contrary to popular scientific belief and because it was funded by Philip Morris.
Oops! I wouldn't call it a study. I'd call it PR work.
Re:Scientist's Firing After 36 Years Fuels 'PC' Debate at UCLA
by msie on Friday September 03, 2010 @02:04AM
(#1658770)
I see you agree with me. It does warrant extra scrutiny.
Frankly, it doesn't matter if the study is carried out correctly or not. All that matters is that a study in some journal says that second-hand smoke is not bad for you.
You need to realize that "better" sources might not report the story because it doesn't fit with their agenda.
I say this as scientist who used to work for a major university in a major national lab. Certain outcomes are not acceptable, even if they are scientifically correct.
Neither are politics, much of the time, and the problem with linking to an article from Fox is the network's slant. I'm not the only person to notice this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1658518 .
Until someone else picks this up and/or tries to see if it's actually true, it doesn't mean jack.
I guess this is a transnational agreement, because faculty move back and forth across the oceans, and their opinions don't change much. "The government" must be a lot more well-organized than I'd suspected.
(Obviously you should take this hearsay anecdote with the proverbial minimal quantity of sodium chloride but I'll try to verify it with some other professors in the department.)
Oops! I wouldn't call it a study. I'd call it PR work.
That's the beauty of science -- it doesn't matter who's involved as long as it's correct.
Frankly, it doesn't matter if the study is carried out correctly or not. All that matters is that a study in some journal says that second-hand smoke is not bad for you.