Re:Did the Manhattan Transfer Use Auto-Tune?
by xpaulbettsx on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:14PM
(#1658080)
Autotune doesn't have to know the sheet music behind what the singer is singing, it's just trying to snap the pitch to any in-tune note - it's the audio equivalent to "Snap to Grid".
Re:Did the Manhattan Transfer Use Auto-Tune?
by nitrogen on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:30PM
(#1658304)
Some older pitch correction devices, like the Lexicon PCM-81, aren't that great at snapping the pitch on their own (or can't do it at all), and need a keyboard playing the correct notes.
Re:Did the Manhattan Transfer Use Auto-Tune?
by chipsy on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:43PM
(#1658325)
A particularly well-known example of live use is the Billy Joel Super Bowl XLI national anthem:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G8smRRyoYGc
The main problem with auto-tuning live is that you're just trading the pitch control for everything else - intonation, vibrato, etc. Exposing that "robot sound" ends up being another way to screw up your performance, and so there's no way to cheat. You still need to be an excellent singer to get close to the studio-perfected sound.
(If you're in the studio, of course, you can do overdubs, and you can use the more sophisticated Auto-Tune competitor Melodyne, which uses batch processing to allow smoother and more detailed corrections including pitch, rhythm and timbre, and in the most recent versions, chord manipulations.)
Re:Did the Manhattan Transfer Use Auto-Tune?
by philwelch on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:10PM
(#1658068)
More "live" records are post-produced than you'd think--recording over mistakes or looping choruses where the singer just left it for the audience to sing.
Re:Did the Manhattan Transfer Use Auto-Tune?
by RK on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:21PM
(#1658095)
I vaguely recall a story about this that said they were using auto-tune at Paul McCartney's actual concerts. Which would not surprise me if it is becoming a standard, simply because it is easy to do nowadays.
It's probably most noticeable when you are so familiar with someone's voice.