News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hou... by addicted on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @03:09PM (#16578850)
There is far far more incentive for AMD and its partners to understate the severity.
Re:Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hou... by Retric on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @03:28PM (#16578996)
I disagree. AMD needs to maintain it's reputation over time. Short sellers make their profit over a few hours/days and don't care if they are proven wrong.

So, AMD has vastly more incentive to be accurate than short sellers.

Re:Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hou... by bigiain on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:20PM (#16580778)
Pity that vast incentive didn't seem to work out when they promoted all these chips as having "Firmware Trusted Platform Module", "Secure Encrypted Virtualization", "AMD Secure Processor", and "AMD Secure OS" as features.

AMDs incentive, like any corporation, is to maximise shareholder value. Same as any tiny little security research firm. If a research firm can maximise their profit buy discovering vulnerabilities and shorting stock before disclosing them, is that any ethically worse than a chip company rushing out flawed hardware with big flashy marketing bullet points claiming how secure they are?

(I'm not saying short-selling chip vendor stocks on the back of vulnerabilities is a way I'd choose to make a living, but surveillance capitalism doesn't seem an "ethically better" industry to work in either...)

Re:Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hou... by Retric on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:28PM (#16580832)
CPU's have real value.

As to ethics that's mostly irrelevant to this discussion. Both sides could have ethical behavior, I am simply pointing out which side has the larger incentives to exaggerate. After all the stock could drop and a short seller could still lose money. They need the stock to drop a lot even over a minor issue.

Re:Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hou... by bigiain on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:50PM (#16581617)
While the dollar value of AMDs incentive is without doubt larger - the existential value of the smaller amount incentivising the researcher is likely more motivating...
Re:Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hou... by bigiain on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @08:43PM (#16581298)
I'd argue that vulnerability research has real value as well.
Re:Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hou... by dahdum on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @03:26PM (#16578984)
On an individual level, it's much less I'd think. Inciting a panic could be life changing amounts of money for the researchers, paid out by the hedge fund returns.

AMD isn't going to crash and burn over these flaws anymore than Intel (at 5 year high) did.