Re:Obama administration: "Piracy is flat, unadulterated theft"
by niels_olson on Thursday September 02, 2010 @05:22PM
(#1657734)
You know, if it were theft, I think the cases would be tried as cases of theft. I love a semantic argument as much as the next guy, but I find I'm most successful in those arguments when I avidly defer to time-proven definitions. And when those definitions have been so thoroughly debated that they have been intrenched in law almost universally consistent across multiple nations and languages, I really defer to those.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_infringement#Comparis...
I hope you take the opportunity at some point in your life to revisit your opinion on this issue.
Re:Obama administration: "Piracy is flat, unadulterated theft"
by wildjim on Thursday September 02, 2010 @05:30PM
(#1657758)
It's still not theft -- i.e. taking something from. It's explicitly a lack of compensation, which is still not "taking something from" -- though there are laws which require compensation for services provided, they vary hugely across the world, and can get people in trouble when they apply their local knowledge in other jurisdictions. Several countries don't apply copyright/patent/IP or even contract law(s) in anything remotely like a USA style (for want of a better sterotype).
"Depriving" is a somewhat loaded term that implies a "take" behaviour to you, but it's just not strictly true.
One way or another, somebody took the time to learn to play some instrument, write a song, record that song, then get it distributed in some manner. All of that costs both time and money, just like designing and building a car or a laptop or any other physical good. If depriving someone of compensation for something they worked to create and distribute isn't theft, I don't know what is.