Re:Coltrane Pitch Diagrams: Wrapping notes around a torus
by beat on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:22AM
(#16576302)
Just intonation leads to giving up on key changes, though. And it gives up the flexibility of the piano and fretted instruments - if you want to play well in a different key, you have to re-tune the piano!
The dominance of equal temperament can probably be traced directly to the rise of the piano in importance.
Re:Coltrane Pitch Diagrams: Wrapping notes around a torus
by zengid on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:48PM
(#16577515)
I don't know about you but I don't own a piano. I do have several computers though, and they all have a soundcard. Dynamic tuning is a problem that can be solved by software!
I'm fine with equal temperament dominating, but it shouldn't be taken for granted as the only system for selecting an intonation. When I went to school for music the only time we talked about intonation was in music history. I'd like to change that.
I feel like taking equal-temperament for granted obscures a lot of the simplest connections. Just intonation has a treasure trove of interesting implications (and challenges), and the math is elementary school stuff [0].
[0] https://music.stackexchange.com/a/33787