Re:Coltrane Pitch Diagrams: Wrapping notes around a torus
by chowells on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:07PM
(#16572502)
Was 5 octaves really an arbitrary choice? It's the point where the circle of fifths gets back to the starting note. (Nevermind that detail that there are no positive integers m, n such that (3/2)^m == 2^n.)
That's not exactly arbitrary - there is a reason to use that range in preference to others.
You could see the Coltrane diagrams as viewing a spiral head-on, so that the spiral nature of the structure is hidden by occlusion.
This would solve the problem of the arbitrary nature of representing only five octaves.