Just an odd takeaway, since that's the expressly stated purpose of most retirement accounts. But fair enough.
This isn't very consistent when the social issue that has really driven these polices into existence is trying to convince lower earners to save for retirement so that the state doesn't have a huge outgoing on pensions etc.
If the article is arguing that everyone pays roughly the same taxes, that would mean we have a de facto flat tax anyway so the incentives should be clear.
> Second, the U.S. fiscal system provides most households with very strong reasons to limit their labor supply and saving.
That would mean unemployment would be low, given the lower labor supply.
> Third, the system offers very high-income young and middle aged households as well as most older households tremendous opportunities to arbitrage the tax system by contributing to retirement accounts.
If one had a crystal ball, yes. Marginal tax rates are at some the lowest in 60 years, so it is entirely possible that they will be higher at the time of retirement withdrawal.
> Fourth, the patterns by age and income of marginal net tax rates on earnings, marginal net tax rates on saving, and tax-arbitrage opportunities can be summarized with one word - bizarre.
Doesn't sound very objective.
thanks to the incredible complexity of the U.S. fiscal system,
it's essentially impossible for anyone to understand her incentive to work
The second line is true regardless if the first. Under what circumstances is $0.3, $0.6 or $.09 worth performing an extra $1 of labor? It depends on how you value your leisure time, whether you have a specific goal for the money in mind, whether your math skills are sufficient to even understand how much extra the $1 will net you, etc. That's not a reason for not simplifying the system, but it is a reason for the first and second argument to be plainly false: households do not, and are often incapable of, reason(ing) based on the fiscal system.So maybe you meant that it's impossible to generalise it to the whole population because everyone has different "goal for the money in mind" and value of "leisure time"?
http://www.kotlikoff.net/sites/default/files/Comparing%20Ave...
http://www.kotlikoff.net/sites/default/files/Does%20It%20Pay...
and perhaps the most practical bit is here:
The paper provides four main takeaways. First, thanks to the incredible complexity of the U.S. fiscal system, it's essentially impossible for anyone to understand her incentive to work, save, or contribute to retirement acounts absent highly advanced computer technology and software. Second, the U.S. fiscal system provides most households with very strong reasons to limit their labor supply and saving. Third, the system offers very high-income young and middle aged households as well as most older households tremendous opportunities to arbitrage the tax system by contributing to retirement accounts. Fourth, the patterns by age and income of marginal net tax rates on earnings, marginal net tax rates on saving, and tax-arbitrage opportunities can be summarized with one word - bizarre.