News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by DoreenMichele on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:41AM (#16568863)
One of the problems with such schemes is that it is not vernacular housing. It is a top down, one size fits all scheme that contains zero local knowledge and no means to incorporate local knowledge.

Vernacular housing is local traditional housing built with local materials and suited to the local climate. So, adobe in the American Southwest and deep porches in the American Southeast so you can have windows open in rainy weather.

It typically winds up working about as well as transplanting a New York apartment to a farm. A New York apartment makes sense in New York. It doesn't make sense on a farm.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by reneherse on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:26PM (#16569704)
In addition, what happens to the local building trades, whether established or nascent? Are they integrated into the scheme or made redundant?

After watching the video, it's evident this method of construction has another disadvantage over the lifecycle of the structure: The walls cannot be easily modified. (And this is a characteristic and complaint of nearly all poured-in-place concrete construction, often cited by institutional caretakers of brutalist buildings.)

An economical house should be able to change and grow according to the needs and means of its owners. That's much more difficult when adding a door or window requires a diamond-blade, water-cooled saw to cut through a thick structural concrete web while avoiding embedded service conduits. In comparison, walls of concrete block, brick, and wooden studs are more readily modified, though each has other favorable and unfavorable characteristics.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by mikepurvis on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:18PM (#16569152)
... and there was even just a discussion a few days ago on HN about Fordlandia: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16537630
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by snissn on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:34PM (#16569301)

    "one size fits all scheme"
Considering the innovation is in 3-D printing a home, I think it can be customizable
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by DoreenMichele on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:59PM (#16569512)
The missing key ingredient will be local information. The hoi polloi from 1st world countries are unlikely to listen to uneducated 3rd world peasants.

In the Great Depression, they gave free bathtubs to dirt poor people in shacks in Appalachia. The shacks had no running water. The locals stuck them on the front porch and used them to store coal, fuel for cooking and winter heat. The monied types that gave them the tubs mocked them for their idiocy. What kind of fool puts a bathtub on the front porch and fills it with coal?

Coming up with multiple variations of top down templates doesn't fix the essential problem here.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by d0lph on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:03PM (#16569551)
> The hoi polloi from 1st world countries are unlikely to listen to uneducated 3rd world peasants.

Kind of harsh and presumptuous.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by DoreenMichele on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:16PM (#16569636)
I spent nearly 6 years homeless. I am American and have about 6 years of college. The hoi polloi didn't want to listen to me as to what I wanted.

I found the degree to which I was given a deaf ear rather harsh. Other than my lack of money, I am essentially one of the hoi polloi. I'm even recently decended from low level German nobility. My maternal grandmother's maiden name started with von and the family sold the title when it fell on hard times.

But I'm poor, so I must be an incompetent dolt who has no clue what is best for me. I'm quite confident that prejudice runs all the deeper towards people who have more differences than just income from the powers that be.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by d0lph on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:44PM (#16569872)
I don't think you are a complete dolt, nor do I think that you are always right in every discussion.

You are making assumptions about large groups of people who I highly doubt are carbon copies of each other.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by Turing_Machine on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:26PM (#16570682)
Sounds like a myth to me.

People in houses without running water do, in fact, own bathtubs and do, in fact, take baths. I know, because I've been one of them.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by DoreenMichele on Monday March 12, 2018 @05:00PM (#16571581)
This is not about Appalachia per se. My recollection is this also occurred in Appalachia. That detail may be inaccurate and is not really terribly important to my point:

http://www.christopherfowler.co.uk/blog/2016/10/15/ps-more-o...

There has been talk about coals being kept in the bath. I know how that story began. In the East End of London, 25 years ago, some well-intentioned people built houses for the working classes and put in baths. The baths were put in the scullery, and had neither a water supply nor a waste pipe. The rents were very high, and the tenants found it necessary to let some of the rooms, and as in those circumstances the fixed bath was found to be more trouble than a portable bath, and as there was no adequate coal cellar, the bath was used as a coal store.

Why give baths to miners? Why give baths to agricultural labourers? They will put coals in the baths.” Why does any woman put coals in the bath? Because she has not been provided with a coal cellar. So long as you are not willing to give her a coal cellar, it is a proper form of protest to go on putting coals in the bath.”

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by jaredhansen on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:13PM (#16569612)
>The hoi polloi from 1st world countries are unlikely to listen to uneducated 3rd world peasants.

Not just unfair/ungrounded, but incorrect as a matter of usage: "hoi polloi"[0] means the exact opposite of what you're using it to mean.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoi_polloi

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by DoreenMichele on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:18PM (#16569656)
Yup, I took Greek in college. I am well aware that it originally meant the people and has come to mean the exact opposite -- the high falutin types. My Greek professor covered that ironic history.

The possibility for misunderstanding is part of why I usually avoid the expression. But I will leave it. I think people here know what I mean by it, and never mind the opening for pretending I don't have a point because we don't agree on this one term.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by benjohnson on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:27PM (#16569720)
>>1st world countries are unlikely to listen to uneducated 3rd world peasants.

There's a balance - it's reasonable to think that the civilizations in the 1st world do have some expertise to offer.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by jlebrech on Monday March 12, 2018 @05:53PM (#16572030)
build one, iterate. the local knowledge will come.