News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by s_m_t on Sunday March 11, 2018 @10:24PM (#16565840)
In certain cities in the United States going to jail for shooting and killing someone is something of a networking retreat for criminals. You plead down to manslaughter and may serve less than 3 years. Great way to jumpstart your career and gain credibility on the streets.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by jMyles on Sunday March 11, 2018 @10:34PM (#16565878)
I need to see some evidence of these claims. I doubt that prison is materially similar to a "networking retreat". Are people really pleading down to manslaughter, after literally shooting and killing someone, and serving less than 3 years?
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by ggg9990 on Sunday March 11, 2018 @10:43PM (#16565906)
The large numbers of prison gangs is evidence of the networking function. And in gang ridden neighborhoods most murders aren’t even solved, and 3 years happens regularly, because of the low evidence an lack of witness cooperation causing prosecutors to cut plea bargains.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by forapurpose on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:56AM (#16566592)
I agree with the GP; I'd need to see some evidence.

> in gang ridden neighborhoods

Gangs are no longer a problem in most American cities, afaik. It's a obsolete myth in the minds of people who never step foot in poor and working-class urban neighborhoods, but they see lots of TV and movies.

Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by ggg9990 on Monday March 12, 2018 @05:41AM (#16566997)
You don't see Crips and Bloods wearing colors but in the several cities I've spent significant time in, there are organized drug-dealing operations with management hierarchy. That, to me, is a gang.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by forapurpose on Monday March 12, 2018 @06:08PM (#16572140)
How would you know those things without being in that 'business'? The current drug problem is disproportionately rural, as far as I know. Crime in cities is at lows going back decades. Again, gang-ridden, drug-dealer filled cities is an obsolete notion among those who don't live in them.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by sametmax on Sunday March 11, 2018 @10:35PM (#16565881)
3 years for manslaughter ? That seems a very, very low sentence for taking a life.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by jschwartzi on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:05PM (#16565974)
Be careful when you react this way. This kind of thinking leads to mandatory minimums for nonviolent drug offenses, shoplifting, and all kinds of petty crimes that aren't typically perpetrated by hardened criminals with violent tendencies. It's the kind of thinking that fills our prisons with people who really belong in therapy or a psych ward.

Killing someone is bad, very bad. But murder charges should be reserved for people who planned to kill someone that day versus being driven to do so in the moment. On its face it might not seem like there's a difference, but there is. It's like the difference between yelling at someone for cutting you off in traffic versus planning exactly how you're going to yell at your boss when you quit in pique. It's the heat of the moment versus the calculation of premeditation.

People do take advantage of the way our justice system judges you partly on intent, but I think that's an essential part of a humane justice system, and some people will always take advantage of our humanity. And I think if we look at the mechanics of plea bargains, this kind of abuse is probably rife. But I don't think the answer is to raise the minimum sentence. I think the answer is to prosecute the correct charges and to prove intent and planning. Or to accept that many of the killings in question really are perpetrated in the heat of the moment and not out of some cunning plan on the part of the killer.

Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by sametmax on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:31PM (#16566041)
Let's say it this way: imagine it was not prison, but a full therapy treatment and rehabilitation. Do you think that 3 years is enough to rehabilitate an adult that all the events in life lead him or her to kill somebody ?

Some people take 10 years to quit smoking.

Also, while I agree with your point on abusing the justice system and not using it for revenge, you must not forget that:

- currently we also use it as a deterrent system. Even if it doesn't work very well. If somebody is capable of killing someone else, there is a huge different between knowing you will pay 3 years or 10 for it. 3 years to get a reputation or get rid of a life road block could be calculated as an acceptable price.

- there is also the way the non-killers will see the system. If people are being honest, and they witness more and more than being a criminal has not the consequences they though is should have, then people will loose any trust they have in the system. It's a very bad long term side effect to have for a society. Really, really bad.

Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by StudentStuff on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:15AM (#16566174)
A murderer will murder, regardless of whether they are in prison for 1 year or 100 years afterward, they are not apt to estimate what a judge will give them for a particular crime. Deterrence for higher level crimes through harsher sentencing is ineffective.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by sametmax on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:09AM (#16566468)
You are talking in absolute, and this is rarely true.

What's "a murderer" ? Are all of them equals ?

Do you think a Yakuza and a an person wanting an inheritance have the same views on violence ?

And what if you have a one year sentence ? One month ? One week ? None ? Do you think there would be no difference ?

Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by forapurpose on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:58AM (#16566598)
It would be great if we had some evidence to back this up.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by acct1771 on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:12PM (#16565996)
The victim sees no difference in either of your examples, so I'm having a hard time agreeing fully.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by kungtotte on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:37AM (#16566242)
Scenario A: you are at a bar and someone starts a fight with you. You fight back and due to unfortunate circumstances they fall and hit their head in such a way that they die.

Scenario B: you are angry at your neighbor for always taking your parking lot. So you acquire a gun, and in the middle of the night you sneak over to his house, break in, and shoot him while he's sleeping.

Two dead victims, two very different sets of circumstances. Should both those cases be prosecuted as murder? Given the same sentence?

Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by acct1771 on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:01AM (#16566306)
I was imagining a scenario of "crime of passion" e.g. when someone catches their wife in bed with another man. Murder is murder.

Self-defense obviously changes that paradigm completely, and because of that, I'd consider that example moving the goalposts of this discussion

Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by jschwartzi on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:15PM (#16569123)
Crimes of passion aren't prosecuted as murder in many jurisdictions. They're prosecuted as manslaughter. The killer didn't plan to kill anyone, but they were provoked to do so by the other parties.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by sametmax on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:12AM (#16566472)
That's why we have judges.

Here we are talking about yakuza, organized crime, not Joe or Jane having one bad moment in life.

Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by scythe on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:31PM (#16566039)
Sentence is more like ten years, parole in three. Manslaughter unlike murder is supposed to be unintentional. Of course if the criminals are "networking" in prison, that should prevent parole, but cost-cutting privatization in the prison industry has ensured that doesn't happen. Likewise the only reason that it's a manslaughter charge in the first place is that witness protection, and therefore cooperation, is dismal. Simply put the legitimacy of the US government has declined in some areas, although this process really kicked off in the 1960s.
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by DrScump on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:42AM (#16566561)

  the legitimacy of the US government
Homicide is very rarely charged as a Federal crime (special cases like assassination or terrorism).
Re:A 1980s study on juvenile crime in Japan sheds light on A... by scythe on Monday March 12, 2018 @06:32AM (#16567196)
I didn't say federal government, now did I? My point is that when people don't respect the authorities, we refer to this as the "legitimacy of the government" and because no state was specified I went with US, because all states and their governments are part of the US. So yes I anticipated your semantic quibble.