News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This architecture tastes like microarchitecture [pdf] by phkahler on Saturday March 10, 2018 @10:40PM (#16561586)
The author basically says "we've been doing it wrong" and doesn't provide an alternative.
Re:This architecture tastes like microarchitecture [pdf] by redshirt on Sunday March 11, 2018 @07:55AM (#16562651)
Meh, for a retrospective paper, I think the authors probably provided more hints as to the future than they really needed to. I feel like they captured the exact reasons why ISA is so difficult to do right. As for “doing it wrong”, I didn’t take it that way. I think the authors lament the influence of what they seem to feel is a mantra that dictates the programmer must deal directly with the hardware versus providing a sufficiently abstract ISA. Building circuits for ML accelerators, etc. is actually damned easy, exposing those to the programmer in a portable way that does not require rearchitectng the program every time you change the accelerator is tough. I literally loathe porting for Intel b/c the AVX insn behave differently and are essentially architecting in the microarch, passing the complexity directly to the programmer. I’d much rather the Risc-V solution or the ARM solution.