News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jacquesm on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:26AM (#1656061)
It's also what made K5 in to a huge echo chamber.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by _delirium on Thursday September 02, 2010 @12:20PM (#1656674)
I guess I didn't find that to be the case, any more than any other forum, at least. In what ways was K5 more of an echo chamber than, say, HN is?
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jacquesm on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:13PM (#1656854)
If you write stuff for your 'own' audience of the K5 members, which will then write stuff as well for you to comment on and so on it's different than if 90% or more of the submitted articles is about stuff from the outside.

It brings in fresh blood, outside perspective and avoid inbreeding.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by _delirium on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:21PM (#1656878)
Ah, I guess that's the part I actually find much better. There's a certain community aspect where people are actually talking to each other, addressing an audience, that leads to much deeper engagement and discussions imo. That's also the feature of good mailing lists, BBSs, and Usenet groups I like best (though there are plenty of bad ones). The link-site thing seems too disjointed, and imo actually leads to more of an echo-chamber effect, because people end up having to pattern-match based on superficial things like headlines. So we get lots of random submissions that seem superficially about hackerdom or startups, but less sustained engagement. I mean, I personally find HN much more echo-chambery than K5 at its peak was. Perhaps personal preference.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jacquesm on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:37PM (#1656923)
Interesting. You've convinced me to re-visit K5 to see what it's like there now.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by _delirium on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:47PM (#1656967)
Haha, I wouldn't suggest it. I still post there, but it's basically a dive bar of old regulars and some old trolls (who are now a bigger proportion, but have been around long enough that they're sort of endearing, like the local drunk). Very little technical content, and nobody ever writes/submits stories any more, although there is occasionally technical stuff in the diaries (Luke from prgmr.com still posts some stuff there). I think early 2000s was its peak, it was on life support by around 2006, and from 2008-present it's been the walking dead.

An interesting question (to me) is what killed it. One might be that Rusty Foster increasingly lost interest in too much active sysadminning, and eventually added a $5 registration fee, which he thought would raise the quality of the userbase, but actually ended up completely killing any new registration. Another might be the rise of blogs. Although I like the submit-to-K5 model, blogs do make it a lot easier to just post on your personal blog and link somewhere if you prefer. I think there are especially economic incentives to write good content on your own blog rather than on a community site these days (you can make a little money from even a personal blog, get pagerank/prestige from it if it's attached to other projects, etc.).

Of course, that's exactly the part I'm ambivalent about, even though I do it too. I think something's lost when you go from 100 people discussing in a community (whether it's a site or a mailing list) to 100 people each trying to build their personal brands.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jacquesm on Thursday September 02, 2010 @08:54PM (#1658243)
So, I did take a look. It's mostly dead. Pity!
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jbellis on Thursday September 02, 2010 @11:47AM (#1656530)
Which "it" are you referring to?
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jacquesm on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:14PM (#1656858)
>> the fact that the site was organized around submission of original articles to Kuro5hin