News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Should this site be visible to Yahoo, MSN crawlers? by superkarn on Wednesday April 16, 2008 @02:38PM (#165458)
I voted to remain visible.

I assume that resource is not a problem for YC. This fact, coupled with YC not having a search feature, leads me to believe that it's better for YC community that this site is indexed by more than just one search engine.

One big reason, as pointed out by Tichy, is that not all of us use Google as our primary search engine. By cutting off Yahoo, MSN, etc, but not Google, you would essentially be forcing us to use it to search the content of this site. Do that and you could be going down a slippery slope.

And I agree with the "ban all or ban none" mentality.

Re:Poll: Should this site be visible to Yahoo, MSN crawlers? by yters on Thursday April 17, 2008 @01:49AM (#166102)
What's the slippery slope?
Re:Poll: Should this site be visible to Yahoo, MSN crawlers? by superkarn on Thursday April 17, 2008 @09:42AM (#166299)
It's a form of censorship, albeit a subtle one with possibly good reasons.

That's reason I voted for "Remain visible to Yahoo, MSN search." Had option two been "Be invisible to all search engines.", then I would've voted for that one. But then YC would need to offer its own search.

Re:Poll: Should this site be visible to Yahoo, MSN crawlers? by ntoshev on Thursday April 17, 2008 @09:11AM (#166274)
At least two dimensions:

- tying the site to specific products. pg may decide firefox browser is the best predictor for being a hacker and ban all other browsers. Would you like that?

- introducing bias to the community. the search engine may be a correct predictor for being a hacker, but what about the false negtives: do we want to exclude the hackers working on MSN search engine from this community, for example? I certainly don't.

Re:Poll: Should this site be visible to Yahoo, MSN crawlers? by yters on Thursday April 17, 2008 @05:20PM (#166698)
That would be a problem if the decision is technology centered. But, it isn't. Technology is only incidental to making HN membership more challenging, and making a certain technology the de facto standard is anti-thetical to challenge.

See why Fisher thinks chess is dead.

Re:Poll: Should this site be visible to Yahoo, MSN crawlers? by ntoshev on Friday April 18, 2008 @10:19AM (#167232)
pg wants to make Google search technology de facto standard for news.yc.
Re:Poll: Should this site be visible to Yahoo, MSN crawlers? by yters on Friday April 18, 2008 @10:50AM (#167254)
Support?