There's your difference. Libertarian Socialists don't believe in private property.
But how can you have an economy based on voluntary cooperation without the understanding that the voluntary aspect depends on the disposition of property at the discretion of its owners?
If some external authority can overrule you as to how your computer or your farm equipment or your land is used, your choice is between complying with their demands or surrendering your means to participate in the economy altogether; in this scenario, voluntarism is undermined.
Without a concept of private property, a voluntary economy cannot exist.
In a Libertarian Socialist society, there would be no external authority. The state doesn't exist. You couldn't own land, but your computer and your farm equipment are possessions, which they make distinct from 'private property.'
Put differently, property as a way of formalizing personal possession relationships is less objectionable to most anarchists (though many are skeptical of actually formalizing it) than property as a way of creating new kinds of ownership. You can see ownership of your house as just a formal ratification of "I live in this house", but ownership of 10,000 acres of land you've never visited is a pure creation of property-deed databases, and is hard to imagine existing without them.
(Whether that's good or bad, or what to do about it, is another story. I consider myself sympathetic to anarchist critiques and ideals, but putting forth workable concrete proposals is hard.)
This distinction, and the claim that government is hat creates the property seems to come from not thinking e notion of personal property thru.
Basically, at some point, you're advocating taking property away from people ewho have up earned it by creating it or by trading their labor for it.
You need a gang, a mafia, or a government to do that, especially when it's 10,0000 acres somewhere that a collective, or corporation, has put together.
The only difference between a collective owning property and a corporation is that a corporation is allowed to make agreements amongst the members for how the corporation is run.
The existence of a government is not necessary for the existence of corporations.
These are not made up properties created by government, but collections of property made up of possibly thousands of individual explicit agreements between people.
To end that have to stick your nose in as third party and break those agreements that people voluntarily entered into before came around.
This is overly simplistic. Locke was a cool guy and all, but not everyone subscribes to his worldview.
> Basically, at some point, you're advocating taking property away from people ewho have up earned it by creating it or by trading their labor for it.
No, I'm not.
Thank you for the discussion. I'm not going to respond to you any more.
If people are free to pursue their economic goals by voluntary cooperation, it presumes a recognition of underlying property rights. In the absence of external control, many would exercise their rights by monetizing their participation in the economy in order to earn a profit. Many others would adopt a broad "open source" ethos. Most would probably engage in a mix of both, in varying circumstances, and at all levels of formalization.
Freedom and openness lead to healthy variation. It's the philosophies that pursue the universal adoption of a single doctrine that are unnatural and destructive, no matter whether they go by the name of "socialism", "capitalism", or otherwise.