Re:'Corporations Are People' Is Built on a 19th-Century Lie
by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @08:08PM
(#16533582)
Legal corporate personhood is exactly the original differentiating factor of the corporate form vs. other business structures (which basically consisted of sole proprietorships and general partnerships at the time, most other forms are newer inventions than the corporation.)
That said, Constitutional corporate personhood is a distinct thing; it is quite possible for legal corporate personhood to be observed without the protections granted to “the people” or “persons” in the Constitution being extended to private corporations (they generally are not extended to juridical/artificial persons which are not private corporations, such as public bodies, despite those bodies also being legal persons.)
The contentious issue about “corporate personhood” is about Constitutional, rather than juridical, corporate personhood. So while you (and the WSJ article you cite) are correct about legal corporate personhood, that's also a bit of a non-sequitur and equivocation in the discussion at hand. (Though it would help if articles like the Atlantic one would expressly identify Constitutional personhood as the issue and contrast it with juridical personhood, so as to clarify the problem domain and forestall this kind of distraction.)
That said, Constitutional corporate personhood is a distinct thing; it is quite possible for legal corporate personhood to be observed without the protections granted to “the people” or “persons” in the Constitution being extended to private corporations (they generally are not extended to juridical/artificial persons which are not private corporations, such as public bodies, despite those bodies also being legal persons.)
The contentious issue about “corporate personhood” is about Constitutional, rather than juridical, corporate personhood. So while you (and the WSJ article you cite) are correct about legal corporate personhood, that's also a bit of a non-sequitur and equivocation in the discussion at hand. (Though it would help if articles like the Atlantic one would expressly identify Constitutional personhood as the issue and contrast it with juridical personhood, so as to clarify the problem domain and forestall this kind of distraction.)