News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ontario wrongly separated families on results of Motheris... by darkerside on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @08:07AM (#16528565)
Something could trivially be done to the same effect. A private party, say an investigative journalist, could submit a number of samples and report on the results (perhaps that happened in this case and that's why we know about it?). But to keep costs under control, instead of testing like this on every lab on a regular basis, that private party could randomly select labs for testing. While they're at it, they'd probably prefer to select labs with complaints, rather than a random sample. And at that point, you have something resembling the system we currently operate under, which has--to be fair--been completely successful (if a bit later than ideal) in identifying this problem lab. But as taxpayers, is it worth instituting a new regulated program over this essentially free solution?

Besides, this seems like a case of closing the barn door after the horse has escaped. Successfully identifying a problem lab--albeit tardily--is a signal the system is working; not that it needs a complete overhaul. Rather consider what completely unrelated problems would benefit from regulatory oversight at a higher return on investment. Focus on those, not on a solved problem.

Re:Ontario wrongly separated families on results of Motheris... by sbov on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @09:27AM (#16529024)
You're assuming there aren't any other problem labs that haven't or won't be discovered. How expensive are these tests? How much of the police's budget is it? Surely you know these things if you are talking return on investment, because you must know these things to actually know what your return on investment is.

25 years is a long time to be improperly ripping apart families. Is there a point at which it becomes a problem? Death tardily solves all your problems after only 80 years, so I assume somewhere between 25 and 80.

Re:Ontario wrongly separated families on results of Motheris... by darkerside on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @08:41AM (#16536227)
I'm not saying it isn't a problem, only that we need to pick and choose where our dollars go. Is this really a better investment than, say, increased funding for public broadcast programming that might discover this kind of thing in a less directed way? That way you don't end up with yet another obsolete program hanging around costing money when this problem is no longer relevant.

And I think the onus is on the suggester to provide data to prove ROI.

Re:Ontario wrongly separated families on results of Motheris... by testvox on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @08:30AM (#16528686)
The essentially free solution cost 25 years worth of bad results.