Re:Is it time to take the Hyperloop seriously? No
by gnode on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @08:21AM
(#16528641)
I don't see any reason why using maglev means the track has to be anything clever. There are methods where the vehicle contains the only active part, and the track can simply be a metal strip, such as servo-levitation (varying the strength of an electromagnet on board the vehicle with feedback), induced current levitation, or by using a rotating set of fixed magnets.
Re:Is it time to take the Hyperloop seriously? No
by lisper on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @09:46AM
(#16529121)
I must confess I'm not up on the details of maglev technology (which is why it's not central to my argument). I have to wonder, though, if maglev is so cheap and easy why hasn't it been deployed more already?
Re:Is it time to take the Hyperloop seriously? No
by Atheros on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @01:46PM
(#16530962)
Because maglev isn't cheap. [This guy](https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/6ogwml/ny_to_dc_in_29_...) runs the numbers of a Hyperloop in a tunnel using maglev.
Re:Is it time to take the Hyperloop seriously? No
by lisper on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @01:54PM
(#16531028)
That is a great link, thank you!
I think it is telling that the best analysis of this issue that anyone has been able to find in this thread has been in a reddit comment.
Re:Is it time to take the Hyperloop seriously? No
by gnode on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @01:03PM
(#16530614)
While the cost of passive maglev track isn't huge, conventional rail networks which you'd be competing with already exist, so typically would only be justifiable for new networks. Safety is another large concern; it's easy to make a fail-deadly maglev train. While maglev trains are the fastest, safety keeps them an emerging technology.
Re:Is it time to take the Hyperloop seriously? No
by lisper on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @01:20PM
(#16530749)
OK... so why do you think that a maglev hyperloop will not be rendered infeasible by the exact same problems?
BTW, going to maglev completely blows the original economic model out of the water. The whole point of the original hyperloop was that the track was going to be cheap because it was just a welded metal tube. Now it's a welded metal tube with a maglev track inside. That's no longer cheap. In fact, it's a reinvention of maglev in a way that makes it even more expensive. If maglev wasn't economically viable before you put it in a tube (and it wasn't) it won't be economically viable after.