Note that Java's originally only generic type, the array, has C#-style reified generics. The early JVM implementors should have felt a bit dirty in providing reified generics support for arrays at the VM-level without at least having a forward-compatible VM-level provision for general reified generics.
See also: syntax-baked reified arrays, slices, maps, and channels in go (but "no generics" right?)
I think they made the right choice at the time. Targeting devices smaller than desktop computers about 5 years before C# (in a time when Moore’s law was in full swing), they had to cram the jvm in much smaller systems than C# targeted.
.NET chose to implement specialised generics. Many people think that is a better tradeoff.