News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Interstellar communication. IX. Message decontamination i... by wyattpeak on Monday March 05, 2018 @02:07AM (#16519308)
No, I'm not, I'm saying that magic intelligence doesn't change the rules of the game.

If I were negotiating with an alien intelligence, I would assume that it could think circles around me, so I wouldn't be about to accept any bargain that I couldn't - fully - think through the ramifications of. I'm not going to accept complicated bargains, only extremely simple ones. This would most probably result in making no bargains at all. So be it.

I reject the notion that a being capable of reason, holding all the cards, is unable to create an unwinnable state for its opponent, when inaction is a possibility. The most intelligent computer in the universe can't beat you at chess if you don't play.

Re:Interstellar communication. IX. Message decontamination i... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday March 05, 2018 @03:35AM (#16519626)
How would you know you’re playing chess, or even that you’re negotiating?

Any sufficiently advanced alien invasion could be indistinguishable from local politics.

I think the paper fails because it assumes a magical hypersmart AI would arrive as a message at a radio telescope.

But if you’re going to magically assume a magical hypersmart AI, you may as well assume it can get here magically without being noticed.

Re:Interstellar communication. IX. Message decontamination i... by jacobush on Monday March 05, 2018 @04:36AM (#16519859)
I wonder from an anthropological view, how these discussions relate to those of the past, about demons.
Re:Interstellar communication. IX. Message decontamination i... by wyattpeak on Monday March 05, 2018 @06:07AM (#16520223)
Agreed, there are a million more convincing ways an alien intelligence could take over, most likely - as you say - without us ever noticing.

I'm just jumping off from the particular assumption that the paper makes.

Re:Interstellar communication. IX. Message decontamination i... by pdonis on Monday March 05, 2018 @11:25AM (#16522093)
> I reject the notion that a being capable of reason, holding all the cards, is unable to create an unwinnable state for its opponent, when inaction is a possibility.

If this is true for you, it's also true for the AI. Which would be a contradiction, similar to the old classic irresistible force meeting immovable object. So the notion you're rejecting is the only consistent possibility.

Re:Interstellar communication. IX. Message decontamination i... by wyattpeak on Monday March 05, 2018 @07:30PM (#16525888)
No, on two counts.

Firstly, we begin with a power imbalance, we're not on a level playing field.

Secondly, there's nothing inconsistent about both parties being able to create an unwinnable state for the other. As I stated earlier in my comment, the most likely outcome is no dealing whatsoever. The only rational alternative is an agreement whose effects we can both perfectly foresee.