News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HP Holds Navy Network ‘Hostage’ for $3.3 Billion by hristov on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @05:25PM (#1650919)
That is why government agencies should always insist on open source everything. It may seem expensive in the beginning, but it will end up cheaper in the end because you will always have a choice for alternative contractors if you are unhappy with one.
Re:HP Holds Navy Network ‘Hostage’ for $3.3 Billion by gvb on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @07:34PM (#1651245)
Open source is the answer to a different question.

The article is talking about configuring networks, providing hardware, providing computer management services, etc. The software involved in the services that are being discussed is pretty incidental, the way IBM's use of linux is pretty incidental to what IBM sells.

As one of the articles primary examples, the Navy does not have the network diagrams and configuration information for their network. Even if they used open source routers, they currently do not have the information they would need to configure those routers.

Re:HP Holds Navy Network ‘Hostage’ for $3.3 Billion by hristov on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @09:21PM (#1651494)
Well, I had a more holistic open source agreement in mind. In such an agreement any configuration information should be included with the source code. Also any custom hardware should also be specified and all rights provided as part of the agreement.

Regardless of how incidental the software is, if the software and configuration is all open source, then it is always possible for a talented engineer or group thereof to pick up the services where the previous contractor leaves.

Re:HP Holds Navy Network ‘Hostage’ for $3.3 Billion by psadauskas on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @05:55PM (#1650995)
And we (the citizens) are paying for it, shouldn't we be able to extract as much value from it as we can? (Or better yet, be able to volunteer time to make it better?)