News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Php-parser written in golang v0.3 is released by pknopf on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:52AM (#16501311)
What is the purpose of this? Just static analysis?

If that is it, you'd probably be better off just using the PHP parser (https://github.com/nikic/PHP-Parser).

If you are writing analyzers for PHP, you must know it enough to right an analyzer in actual PHP. Why Go?

I can't see a lot of people using this.

Re:Php-parser written in golang v0.3 is released by sshine on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:28AM (#16501548)
> What is the purpose of this? Just static analysis?

I'm not sure about the "Just" here.

The opportunities for writing code transformation tools are abundant. E.g. a PHP IDE that isn't written in PHP, a linting tool, a preprocessor for an embedded DSL. It isn't obvious to me that the tooling for a language like PHP need to be written in PHP.

> Why Go?

Go isn't a bad choice for writing parts of a compiler. The parser itself was, however, written with the parser generator goyacc rather than native Go code:

https://github.com/z7zmey/php-parser/blob/master/php7/php7.y

Taking a goyacc file like this and porting it to another YACC is a lower effort than starting from scratch. In such a way, this project delivers not just "a PHP parser with xx% coverage in Go", but a shortcut to writing PHP parsers in any language with a decent YACC.

One way this project is structured that I don't particularly like is that each node in the AST corresponds to a file. For a programming language with algebraic types (ML, Haskell), having the AST definition in a single file is quite typical.

https://github.com/z7zmey/php-parser/tree/master/node/expr

Re:Php-parser written in golang v0.3 is released by johannes1234321 on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:28AM (#16502155)
> Taking a goyacc file like this and porting it to another YACC is a lower effort than starting from scratch. In such a way, this project delivers not just "a PHP parser with xx% coverage in Go", but a shortcut to writing PHP parsers in any language with a decent YACC.

There's already a yacc file for PHP's parser, part of the PHP runtime: https://github.com/php/php-src/blob/master/Zend/zend_languag...

Re:Php-parser written in golang v0.3 is released by chamton on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:58AM (#16501360)
This project states that it was "inspired by" Nikita's parser, but to me that raises even more questions about its existence.

nikic/PHP-Parser is feature-complete/mature/stable and developed by one of the most knowledgeable members of the PHP internals core development team. It is the library powering many PHP dev tools; static analysis included.

I can see that creating a tool like this is an excellent learning experience, but I don't see why anyone else should care.