News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the West Got China Wrong by coldtea on Friday March 02, 2018 @06:03AM (#16500554)
>So you don't go from nomad tribes to democratic regimes in one step.

That doesn't exactly contradict what the parent said. If anything it supports it.

Precisely because "you don't go from nomad tribes to democratic regimes in one step" modern "Middle Eastern countries work best (as in, remain relatively stable)" as non-democracies.

>The Middle East is not composed of countries, all the borders on the map were artificially created by colonial powers

That's true, but those artificially created countries are still all we have, and are still countries (states) in all senses of the world, and those are the parent was talking about.

Re:How the West Got China Wrong by ekianjo on Friday March 02, 2018 @07:50AM (#16500995)
> and are still countries (states) in all senses of the world, and those are the parent was talking about.

What is true? If you ask locals they don't have any feeling of belonging to any larger-than-them nation, they clearly describe themselves by the community/tribe they come from. This is the only reality that matters.

Re:How the West Got China Wrong by coldtea on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:50AM (#16502434)
>If you ask locals they don't have any feeling of belonging to any larger-than-them nation, they clearly describe themselves by the community/tribe they come from.

Rural locals? Because city locals, and increasingly rural locals as well, will feel like belonging to a larger-than-them nation.

>This is the only reality that matters.*

Obviously not. This might be the only reality they know, but in the outside world, the state they belong to, their government and the general national identity the have to live under matters as well. When such a state is at war with another state, it's not a tribal matter anymore.