> It is a bit disturbing that he took everything exactly...
Still think they sound legit?
Well, his linkedin.com profile has about 400 connections, and I've got about 5 or 6 people linking us, so I know he is a real person who has real connections and real startups. Judy's Book had a huge following, and I have seen him in the local paper here and there.
But, it is definitely concerning. I wrote him an email just now and gave him the link to this thread. If he writes me back I'll let you all know.
It is a bit disturbing that he took everything exactly... even the parenthetic remarks which make him sound like PG.
But, other than that glaring trust-killer, it does seem pretty cool to have an alternative to YC, which is just not feasible for me.