News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Old Smartphones Are a Problem for Apple and Samsung by kyboren on Thursday March 01, 2018 @12:07PM (#16493820)
> I'm happy to trade some control over my phone for assurances that it will have an up-to-date OS that gets security updates in a timely manner.

Unfortunately, you have things just about perfectly reversed. Using stock firmware on Android devices typically leaves a few months' lag time between upstream AOSP patch release and OTA updates for your phone. In contrast, LineageOS devices get updates every week; sometimes LineageOS beats even Google at issuing security updates.

Further, OEMs often discontinue updates after a couple years, while LineageOS will support your device for years and years.

Your tradeoff is really to lose control over your phone for a less-up-to-date OS, (frequently) months-old unpatched vulnerabilities, and a short support period. Your point about users not wanting to root their phones and install another OS still stands, but I dispute your perceived advantages to using stock Android crapware.

PS: Check out the Moto G4 Plus. It has a decent processor, 4GB of RAM, 64GB of storage, a microSD card slot, all the bells and whistles (fingerprint reader, GPS, LTE, etc.), full LineageOS support, and all for ~$220 on Amazon.

Re:Old Smartphones Are a Problem for Apple and Samsung by wilsonnb on Thursday March 01, 2018 @01:38PM (#16494769)
The phone that I was referencing with my comment is my Pixel 2 (and the Pixel I had before it) which gets OS updates faster than any other Android phone. Possibly not quite as fast as LineageOS gets them, but I imagine they are pretty neck and neck in that regard.

I used to use a Samsung Galaxy S4 with CyanogenMod for the security reasons you mention, though. I agree that LineageOS is more secure than most Android phones because the update model is so bad. Sometimes I forget because it's actually quite nice on the Pixel line.