News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by aresant on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:47AM (#1648666)
This is a BRILLIANT feature that I hope stimulates somebody on HN to build around Outlook.

GMAIL hovers around 5% of email client usage.

Outlook still owns somewhere between 35 - 43%.

MSFT was moving in this direction and had a decent solution out a few years back called Email Prioritizer.

Of course, they tossed before it made it out of labs.

Xobni is too complex IMO, what's so compelling about Google's system is how simple it is - it just works, it fits right in. Nice job.

http://www.officelabs.com/projects/emailprioritizer/Pages/De...

http://visibleranking.com/2010/05/most-popular-email-clients...

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by jlouis on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @07:25AM (#1649010)
I think Gmail has much more than 5% of the market. It may be that Outlook is installed on 35-45% of all computers, but nobody currently has numbers for the use of the application. If I can get away with it, I prefer forwarding mails so I don't have to deal with Outlook.

And so should all sane companies: Outlook waste their time.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by qeorge on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @10:17AM (#1649437)
1) The parent's link indicated that this is real usage data, from Campaign Monitor. CM and similar use tracking pixels, and can detect what client is being used to open the email.

2) I use Outlook all the time, as do many people I work with. Gmail is great for webmail, but its not a replacement for Outlook, especially if you rely heavily on contacts, calendar, tasks, or search.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by weavejester on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @11:26AM (#1649657)
Gmail is great for webmail, but its not a replacement for Outlook, especially if you rely heavily on contacts, calendar, tasks, or search.

Really? I find Google Apps to be better in all four of those categories, especially search. What makes Outlook superior in those categories?

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by ricardo on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @12:35PM (#1649938)
Outlook's market share isn't directly correlated to its capabilities. Many large organizations force their employees to use Outlook as their corporate standard.
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by mike-cardwell on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:00PM (#1650265)
Outlook searches within attachments. GMail doesn't.
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by camiller on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @04:31PM (#1650783)
So Campaign Monitor is a email marketing tool. Gmail excels at segregating unsolicited marketing into a folder called "spam". So when I don't open those emails it makes Google look like a smaller proportion than those email clients that don't filter so well. Also, by default gmail does not open graphics (like tracking pixels) when opening a message.

--just say'n

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by levesque on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @11:45AM (#1649723)
I work from multiple locations often, having my contacts, emails, calendar and tasks available from any location is very important to me. The only feature in which I think gmail is lacking/lagging behind is the tasks one.

I've tried using synchronization tools before but they often deal with only one aspect at a time and do so rather poorly (last time I checked, about 1 and a half year ago)

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by mike-cardwell on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @01:31PM (#1650169)
GMail didn't support delegation or folder sharing last time I checked. Those are important requirements for many organisations.

This new feature GMail have announced is trivial and unimportant compared to many other features they could release.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by mike-cardwell on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @01:47PM (#1650227)
If you're downvoting because you disagree, at least explain why. The lack of folder sharing and delegation would both be show stoppers if my organisation was considering moving to GMail.

This new auto-filtering mechanism wouldn't even make it on to the interesting features list, let alone the desirable or required lists.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by willscott on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:36PM (#1650406)
Gmail does have delegation for apps users. It looks like it's only available for 'premiere' accounts, but that makes some sense when you think about who's likely to make use of it.

http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?hl=en&ctx=m...

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by mike-cardwell on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:43PM (#1650436)
That's good to know.
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by sublemonic on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:09PM (#1650289)
I think HNers generally disagree with your statement:

This new feature GMail have announced is trivial and unimportant compared to many other features they could release.

The gmail team is not known for adding trivial or unimportant features. They probably deserve more credit than you are giving them.

Also, I'm not sure how delegation and folder sharing are related to email. Perhaps you could elaborate?

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by mike-cardwell on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:21PM (#1650337)
We have to disagree on the importance of this latest feature then.

Folder sharing: User A gives read or read/write access on one of their email folders to user B. I don't think I've ever used a mail service which doesn't support this simple long standing feature of email.

Delegation: User A delegates permission to user B to organise events in their Calendar, or to send mail on their behalf.

Delegation is very useful for people with secretaries or PAs. Folder sharing is very useful for people working in teams or all kinds.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by xiongchiamiov on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @06:23PM (#1651069)
I have absolutely no desire to give anyone else access to my email, and I'd hazard a guess that this is the case for many other users as well. I do want the ability to send mail as another person (I have some 10-odd email accounts), but Gmail already handles that.

While this new feature may not be useful for corporate users, that doesn't mean it's not useful for users in general.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by mike-cardwell on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @06:58PM (#1651169)
I have absolutely no desire to send mail as another person, and I'd hazard a guess that this is the case for many other users as well. I do want the ability so share mail folders with other people, and GMail doesn't handle that.

While this new feature may be useful for some users, that doesn't mean it's useful for users in general.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by btilly on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @02:29AM (#1652043)
What fraction of users actually want folder sharing?

I've personally been using email since 1992, and I've never once used such a feature, nor has anyone asked me to use it. This is despite my having worked on a fair number of very productive teams.

Now I don't know how you personally use it. But I'm fairly sure that if I looked at your desired workflow using it, I could find another that was equally effective that didn't use it. Better yet, my alternative would be much more convenient for any software developers who don't happen to be working in a Windows environment.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by mike-cardwell on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @08:05AM (#1652504)
> "What fraction of users actually want folder sharing?"

How on Earth would I know that?

We use folder sharing extensively at the University I work at. We have a folder structure which is shared by all staff which we call the Archive. People move email into the Archive which is owned by their role and which needs to be kept and shared with others. So you've never used folder sharing? I can show you several thousand people who have...

The ACL extension for IMAP looks as though it came out about 13 years ago!

> "Now I don't know how you personally use it. But I'm fairly sure that if I looked at your desired workflow using it, I could find another that was equally effective that didn't use it."

You know you could find a better workflow than the one I'm using, even though you don't know what I'm doing? magic.

> "Better yet, my alternative would be much more convenient for any software developers who don't happen to be working in a Windows environment."

The above makes no sense whatsoever and proves you completely missed the point. This isn't a Windows feature. I'm using it from Thunderbird on an OSX box right now, connecting to Dovecot IMAP server on a Linux box. Courier IMAP also supports it, as does Exchange and CommuniGate Pro, Cyrus and most open source webmail applications and email clients...

GMail doesn't support the IMAP ACL extension, nor does the webmail interface support any sort of sharing. That is a severe limitation.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by smackfu on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @09:45AM (#1649334)
GMail isn't even that popular for webmail. It's just that it's insanely popular among the tech types.
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by ruff on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @06:14PM (#1651050)
Don't know if it still does it but ClearContext use to provide this exact solution for Outlook. It prioritized your Inbox based people and e-mails that you haven't responded to yet.

http://www.clearcontext.com/user_guide/contacts.html

The product seems to have chased off into GTD-land, but the sort of the Inbox was really useful.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by devahaz on Friday September 03, 2010 @03:28PM (#1660778)
Hi, I'm the CEO of ClearContext. We have focused the last couple of years on including this type of functionality as part of our project management product, but we plan to release a simple free product for Outlook users focused just on identifying your most important messages. We'll start beta-testing that product this month.
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by vecter on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @08:30PM (#1651379)
Xobni doesn't claim to solve the mailbox triage problem. That's a really hard problem.
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by gduffy on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @02:31AM (#1652047)
Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by vecter on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @09:39AM (#1652737)
That's almost a direct quote from Adam Smith's mouth from a talk he gave at MIT startup bootcamp. I don't have the link to the video at hand, but I distinctly remember him saying, with a pause for emphasis, "Xobni does not solve the email triage problem."

I understand you worked at Xobni, so I cede that you probably know more than I do. Either way, that was the message he was trying to send.

Re:Email overload? Try Priority Inbox by barmstrong on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @03:05AM (#1648691)
Yep - their implementation looks great (at least at first glance).