A few thoughts:
1. Many schools who are willing to give up on the "traditional" job candidate profile are still have a very hard time hiring. I know this from many, many conversations with department and search committee chairs and lower-ranked places.
2. Hiring non-phds isn't always an option for higher-ranked (and especially mid-ranked) institutions. It'd be great if Google only used the data they collect in ways that enhance their users' experience. But it's unreasonable to expect an ad company to not use their data assets to sell ads. There's something analogous going on with hiring non-phd faculty to teach -- institutions involved in a rankings war should only care about maximizing educational outcomes, but we live in the real world and metrics do matter.
3. Most importantly, maybe these places are right to be skeptical! Engineering isn't teaching, and many of those who can do, cannot teach. I've seen a lot of situations where semi-retired industry folks don't take teaching seriously. The permeated anecdotes from industry are valuable, but not valuable enough to compensate for poorly structured courses or failing to explain tree rotations in an intelligible way. It doesn't help that teaching loads demand a 40 hour week, but teaching salaries only pay for 15-20 hours of even semi-retired engineering time.
Many of these teaching positions are in the range where you will be dependent on social security / medicare in order to retire. I consider that dependence effectively poverty in this country. Demographics, budget, and political climate all suggest to me that these two safety nets won't be available in 30 years.
When you're working from 18 or 21 onwards and saving, mid 5 figures over your whole life translates into a survivable retirement.
However, if you don't start saving for retirement until after graduate school (late 20s) and at that point start off at mid 5 figures with terrible benefits, little upward pressure on your salary, and lots of student loans, you're basically dependent upon the government for any retirement. Especially if you care to reproduce.
So, some of these teaching jobs really are poverty wages, given the opportunity cost of graduate school. The poverty comes at 65, but it does come.
What these places need to do is pay well and reduce course loads. But many of them cannot afford to do either.
(Oh BTW google's shooting you emails every week or two.)
Not compared to the income one can make by ditching Academia and entering the workforce. The pay is terrible, full stop. Comparing it to poverty is a pretty bad idea as well.
Clearly academia doesn't want to pay for the talent, so they shouldn't be shocked when they can't get talent.
I'm not sure I understand why you're treating academia as separate from "the workforce."
> Comparing it to poverty is a pretty bad idea as well.
You're right, but I think there's a valuable point of comparison between poverty and jobs outside of academia. And while this is not true in all cases, I think it's fair to say that many academic jobs in CS can provide a comfortable living wage for a small family.
> Clearly academia doesn't want to pay for the talent
In many cases, they can't pay for the talent. At least not to what some companies are prepared to pay for the same people.
Not in certain fields when you consider opportunity cost
> especially when compared to those living in conditions of poverty.
I really hope that we're not going to set the baseline of comparison at poverty levels for the people that can obtain faculty positions in CS.
[1] https://salaries.texastribune.org/search/?q=Assistant+Profes...
lecturer: $80K
assistant: $110K
associate: $110-130K
full: $150-190K
BTW, I see that the UofM CS dept. employs a lot more (3X?) lecturers in CS now than they did 15 years ago -- another sign of high demand/low supply for PhDs in academe.
Or they leave for an industry job before grad school, because a Ph.D is not a money-making proposition compared with three to five years of experience while making a salary.
But the biggest problem is this: academics are afraid of anyone who hasn't demonstrated commitment to their system by earning a Ph.D, writing a thesis, and accepting terrible wages and living conditions for a number of years as junior or adjunct faculty. So the number of 50 year old software engineers who decide to semi-retire and take up an academic position is effectively zero.