News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Forget the Courts — Apple May Fight Mac Clones With Tech by dcurtis on Tuesday April 15, 2008 @10:34PM (#164815)
Yeah, but they're arguing a level higher than that. They're saying the security measures Apple is using are illegal. In that case, the DMCA is rendered irrelevant, right? You can't protect illegal protection schemes.
Re:Forget the Courts — Apple May Fight Mac Clones With Tech by pius on Tuesday April 15, 2008 @10:42PM (#164823)
That's an interesting point. Now's a good time to say IANAL and I'm just speculating, but as I understand it they're not really arguing that Apple's security measures are illegal, but that their business practices are illegal; Apple is entitled to have whatever security they'd like. If that's true, then the DMCA violation would still stand.
Re:Forget the Courts — Apple May Fight Mac Clones With Tech by wright on Wednesday April 16, 2008 @04:17AM (#165002)
Nah, the DMCA bites the bucket in cases like that. It was already overturned for a garage door opener and a printer manufacturer.

You can't claim DMCA protection in cases where you are simply trying to shut out competition. Others are allowed to be interoperable.