News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kind reminder: please (re)read the HN guidelines by bpyne on Monday August 30, 2010 @09:03PM (#1648074)
The noise category assumption is a fair one. "Work harder" is a vague recommendation. Are there more specific recommendations you could make?

No, a discussion would create noise, which would not be valuable for the HN community. A voluntary, anonymous, tip about what made the downvoted comment noise would be more than sufficient. To avoid it becoming a discussion, no reply would be allowed. (Just to throw a half-baked idea out.)

Downvotes could easily become learning exercises that boost the comment quality over time.

Re:Kind reminder: please (re)read the HN guidelines by swolchok on Monday August 30, 2010 @09:09PM (#1648093)

    The noise category assumption is a fair one. "Work harder" is a vague recommendation. Are there more specific recommendations you could make?
Don't post just because you can. Don't echo comments others have made. Don't post "obligatory" comments or content-free Reddit memes. Say something meaningful that is not immediately obvious.

Don't treat post writing as an exercise in upvotability optimization.