Erm ... what do you consider "the market price"?
I suppose it's not the price that people actually pay for something in the market, as then even the state paying for all your diesel needs would still not qualify as a subsidy (if the state pays for it, you don't pay anything, that would make the market price zero under that definition, so the free diesel would not be under market price, therefore not a subsidy, right?)?
But what is the market price, if it's not what people pay?
> While many of the effects are similar, it is not the same.
So ... what is the difference then?
A subsidy results in a sale price below the equilibrium price while sellers receive payments above the equilibrium price. An excise tax has the opposite effect.
Different excise taxes on competing products may lead consumers to prefer one over the other, but still results in less consumption of both products than the market would without intervention.