News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by pascalxus on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:56PM (#16478863)
The middle class can no longer afford to remain in CA. A combination of egregious housing policies and other anti-bussines/anti-people regulations stifle the economic well being of it's inhabitants. It's sad to see people having to leave behind their friends and families, for all this. Not only are people leaving, but the birth rate for millineials in CA hasn't been this low since the great depression: http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-birth-rate-...
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by capkutay on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:19PM (#16479076)
I'm surprised this isn't covered more, but this talk of boosting 'affordable', actually government subsidized housing as a solution doesn't seem like an actual solution to me either.

how many middle class families are going to register with a government entity, stay under low yearly income limits to 'qualify' for affordable housing? number of kids you have in your family is factored in as well...becoming a metric that factors into your qualification for housing.

seems sort of orwellian to me. we should be creating bills to expedite all housing. not just subsidized housing.

http://sd11.senate.ca.gov/news/20170123-senator-wiener-relea...

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by cobookman on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:06PM (#16479801)
For SF you don't need To stay under the limit. Technically you could apply as a college student, buy a BMR condo, then start your 6 figure job while keeping the place.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by pascalxus on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @11:18PM (#16489632)
Your right. I never said anything about subsidized housing. We just need vastly more supply of market rate housing to bring it down to a level where it's cost effective enough for everyone
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by krausejj on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:07PM (#16478961)
a solution is on the table— sb-827. please research it. californians (and i am one too) need to stop complaining and start fixing things. this bill fixes things. it needs our attention and support.

UPDATE: sb-827 prevents local governments in california from banning density near public transit. it represents the most radical housing bill in recent california history, because it rebalances control from hyperlocal municipalities to the state level. it could unlock 3m housing units in a state building <100k a year. that's 30 years of pent-up supply, and it could actually affect market prices.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by vondur on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:51PM (#16479312)
Here in Southern California, we are running out of room for housing. You can basically drive all the way from San Diego to Santa Barbara, or from the coast to about a 100 miles inland and it's all city. Unless you are going to tear down existing housing and rebuild with more high density housing which is just cost prohibitive. I figure at some point availability of water will become the limiting factor.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by nopinsight on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:10PM (#16479812)
Since agriculture uses the bulk of water, it is a matter of allocation and proper pricing.

California’s is a knowledge-based economy—Agriculture contributes but a small percentage to it (about 2%). Why should we restrict the number of productive people who can live in the state in favor of crops?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_California

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by yellowapple on Thursday March 01, 2018 @12:02AM (#16489806)
There's an absurd number of crops that would effectively disappear from American (and probably even global) diets if California started to downsize its agriculture. The Central Valley is very unique in having both fertile soil and year-round reasonably-temperate weather. That's a resource which - if anything - ought to be prioritized and expanded to as high of a degree as possible.

Water is quite literally the only issue, and it's a very recent one. It's also an easy one to solve: follow Israel's lead and build desalinization plants up the wazoo. That, or pray that we mountain folks keep getting decent winters to sustain the summers. Pushing ranching (which is disproportionately-water-intensive) out-of-state is another option, as is figuring out ways to reduce ranching's water impact.

As for the low proportion of California's economy to which agriculture contributes, it's worth remembering that agriculture doesn't exactly have high margins. California's farms in particular are also heavily staffed with undocumented labor (which I reckon will skew a lot of data in all sorts of crazy directions).

Put simply: crops ain't the problem, and scapegoating the "dumb and dirty" farmers was already a tired trope five years ago, let alone now.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by DougN7 on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @09:28AM (#16483159)
There is the small issue of those productive people needing to eat...
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by nopinsight on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @09:53PM (#16489298)
California exports a lot of food, including to other countries. It does not need to have excess food supply given its economic structure.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by DougN7 on Thursday March 01, 2018 @11:34AM (#16493424)
California exporting a lot of food is a great thing. How about instead of destroying a major source of food, people simply move away from California?
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by nopinsight on Friday March 02, 2018 @03:10PM (#16505237)
The world has an excessive amount of food production capacity. That is why all the subsidies many governments give to prop up their farmers.

I thought a key American ideal is freedom. Why would you want to restrict people’s freedom and only give the privilege only to the few who just happen to be born early enough to get property there? (Even some California native sons and daughters cannot afford to buy a home in their own home city.)

By the way, flippant answers are not appreciated. Consider reading more about the topics before giving thoughtful answers?

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by krausejj on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:56PM (#16479344)
some redevelopment is likely to occur. McKinsey did a deep dive here and came up with a 3 million number for new units (https://www.mckinsey.com/global-themes/urbanization/closing-...)

this wouldn't happen overnight, but it would be the biggest increase in housing supply in recent history. there are quite a few maps you can google to see where the increased density would be likely to go: https://transitrichhousing.org/ (it looks like most of SB will not be affected, because you don't have as much transit as California's other cities)

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by dcldcl on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:21PM (#16479094)
SB-827: Planning and zoning: transit-rich housing bonus [0]

Edited: Nevermind, I see your other posts below.

Original: I'm a urban California resident... (have been for a good chunk of my life). I'm don't see why this is a solution to the problem of why people are leaving the state.

Can you provide your thoughts on why you believe this to be the solution? Or links to material you've found to be compelling?

[0] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by krausejj on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:38PM (#16479232)
https://www.vox.com/cities-and-urbanism/2018/2/23/17011154/s... is the best article so far, but the nber introduction from 2002 is a great background piece (http://www.nber.org/papers/w8835)

also, i've considered this quite a bit and written on it mediocre-ly: https://medium.com/@justinkrause/how-to-save-san-francisco-8...

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by dcldcl on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @07:28PM (#16479550)
If I get the idea behind it, we're going to eliminate/reduce parking requirements and give a density bonus. And the primary way this will be feasible is if (more) people take transit.

Then the thing about SB827 that doesn't make sense to me is why the bonus is only for residential development.

Yes, I understand that residential pricing is the problem. But, we're not just taking transit to our friend's house. We're taking transit to work and services.

Sure, I can see this working in San Francisco given the transit coverage and relatively centralized business core. (Scary though given the quality of service that Muni/BART offers presently.)

But in LA/SD/Greater Bay Area/Sacramento? I think there's a ton of jobs that aren't off transit lines. Doesn't seem to work well there.

Yes, I agree that things probably need to change in California. But SB827 seems to be about stirring the pot.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by prawn on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @01:17AM (#16481081)
What density are they talking about? If 4-6 levels, then you can likely accommodate residential in the upper tiers and light commercial (consultancies, etc) at the bottom.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by anthonyleecook on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:13PM (#16479027)
interesting!! will take a deeper look
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by kumarm on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:04PM (#16478942)
[California has been experiencing a years-long downward trend that likely stems from the recession, a drop in teenage pregnancies and an increase in people attending college and taking longer to graduate, therefore putting off having children, said Walter Schwarm, a demographer at the Department of Finance. When people do complete their schooling, they're interested in taking some time to pursue their careers or other goals, he said.]

Except recession everything else that is contributing to lower birth rate seems side effect of progress.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by yakz on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @07:01PM (#16479384)
Coming from south-eastern US and visiting Mountain View / Palo Alto on business several times, the property valuations are amazing to me. Poorly maintained looking ranch homes with bad landscaping and giant Land Rovers, Porsches, Jags in the driveway or on the street. Downtown looks almost like my semi-rural hometown except there are full parking garages and you have to park under an over-pass. It's a weird place.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by jjtheblunt on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:59PM (#16480334)
There's a word for that: shitty.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by mehrdadn on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:03PM (#16478937)
> but the birth rate for millineials in CA hasn't been this low since the great depression

I think this might need a rewording to convey whatever idea you were trying to convey, because I have a hunch there weren't many millennials around during the Great Depression. :-)

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by dragonwriter on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:11PM (#16478997)
And the birth rate for Millennials has been zero for pretty much all of history, except for a short blip on the late 20th Century. And that's not an effect limited to CA.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by corpMaverick on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:47PM (#16479293)
Don't forget the other blip on the late 10th Century.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by kridsdale1 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:58PM (#16480782)
William the Conqueror’s father was a millennial.
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by mehrdadn on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @05:54AM (#16482129)
And Jesus was born just a little too late to be a millenial. :(
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by lambda on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:14PM (#16479036)
I think it's fairly clear that they mean "the birth rate for people in the 20-35 age range, which happens to coincide with the millenials at the moment."
Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by thephyber on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:28PM (#16479156)
It's pretty clear what they meant, but humorously even your rewording isn't accurate.

A named generation is static, based on the birth dates. The "20-35 age range" is dynamic, anchored to the present time.

Also, named generations (like "Millennials", "Gen Y", "Gen X", "Baby Boomers", etc) don't have rigid definitions. Some media groups define it as starting as early as 1976 and others as late as 1984, which is 50% of your "20-35" range.

In the end, the boundaries of named generations are more or less arbitrary unless there is an extremely specific event which defines it (Baby Boomers started with an explosion of birth rates immediately after the end of WW2).

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by lambda on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:26AM (#16480883)
> A named generation is static, based on the birth dates. The "20-35 age range" is dynamic, anchored to the present time.

Yes, that's why my phrasing used "at this moment." At this moment, millenials are around an age range of 20-35 years old, give or take a bit depending on the very fact that you point out, there aren't well defined boundaries and the exact age range could vary. I was very careful to include "at this moment" in my phrasing, for the reason that you point out. I didn't bother to hedge about the unclear boundaries of the millenial generation, since that wasn't the topic at hand, but yes, these terms are somewhat vague.

The actual article cited simply discussed the nationwide birthrate at different points in time; it didn't talk about particular generations.

Given that millenials are currently the generation that are of prime child-bearing age, it's pretty clear what the original poster meant "people of child bearing age right now, who happen to be millenials, are having less children than those of child bearing age at any point since the great depression."

The original phrasing was humorously incorrect, I just thought that asking for clarification was a bit much, since it was pretty clear what they meant to say, it was just a funny mistaken phrasing.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by dragonwriter on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:16PM (#16479054)
> The middle class can no longer afford to remain in CA

It seems like the immigration is mostly the middle and upper middle class, as those terms are most often used [0]. The out-migration looks to be mostly below national median income.

[0] which, sure, is the upper income end of the working class and not the petit bourgeoisie, for the most part, but aside from me, no one seems to use “middle class” to mean that in the US.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by jahewson on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:41PM (#16479251)
> The middle class can no longer afford to remain in CA

But that's not what most of the data shows. The bulk of the data shows lower-income, lower education Californians moving out. The strongest peak is for minimum wage incomes.

While middle class incomes are still shown as leaving CA, it's far less than those at the lower end. For me the starkest and most concerning contrast is not wealthy vs. poor, but young vs. old.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by dahdum on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:22PM (#16479867)
They're moving in part because CA continues to push out businesses that require unskilled labor, through a combination of taxes, minimum wage hikes, regulations, and other roadblocks. Generally it's dressed up as a Good Thing, but I'm not so sure.

CA has the highest poverty rates in the country, along with the highest taxes. SF is rich as all hell, but can't keep feces and needles from littering the sidewalks or car windows intact. Cupertino had virtue signaling signs up supporting undocumented immigrants and welcoming them to their city - but their housing policy shows only the rich of any race or creed are welcome.

All the while places like Houston are booming, with development happening everywhere, affordable housing, diverse population, and jobs.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by Govannon on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @11:06AM (#16483865)
>CA has the highest poverty rates in the country

By what metric? looking at the census data, it appears the poverty rate of California, while not great, is certainly not the worst.

https://www.census.gov/data-tools/demo/saipe/saipe.html?s_ap...

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by dahdum on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @09:31PM (#16489204)
Census bureau, factoring in cost of living.

http://www.politifact.com/california/statements/2017/jan/20/...

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by JustAnotherPat on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:18PM (#16479068)
> The middle class can no longer afford to remain in CA. A combination of egregious housing policies and other anti-bussines/anti-people regulations

To me this doesn't make sense. Middle class can't survive in CA because too many people get paid middle class and up in CA. Is it 'anti-people' to pay teachers 70+k? Or is a state like WV more 'pro-people' where teachers are going on strike because they get no raises. There are a lot of wealthy businesses in CA. You have to be richer than in other places to actually feel rich.

truth is, the problem is too much competition and there always has to be somebody at the bottom. Look at the inflow of people. People with high incomes and advanced degrees.

Re:California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration by ddlatham on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:15PM (#16479039)
It seems like this is now the middle class experiencing the same pain that gentrification inflicts on the lower class as the cost of housing continues to climb.