News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: My rule of thumb for initial estimation by briandoll on Monday August 30, 2010 @07:24PM (#1647844)
There is just so much lost in that phone-tag of a conversation between the actual customer and the actual developer in the scenario I think you're describing. Agile estimating techniques seem to provide a reasonable level of expectation, while placing more importance on collaboration between the product owner and the developers.

Once you add development managers, project managers (who are often re-estimating for you, adding or reducing a number to align with some other expectation) and a product owner who's only hearing numbers rather than the details, it's a very lossy conversation.

How many estimates have you given where you wish you could have said "but if we just do it like this, it'll only take x% of the time", and how well was that communicated to your client?

I just think software estimating as a way of holding a conversation about a product under development is unproductive at best, and often leads to an inferior product .

Re:Tell HN: My rule of thumb for initial estimation by RiderOfGiraffes on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:47AM (#1648667)
I'm sorry, but that meant absolutely nothing to me.

Your final line was:

  > I think it's best to stop estimating and start shipping.
My point is that when I need a broad plan of what to implement, how much scope to include, when something will be ready by, and how many people will be required, I need to estimate. Sometimes I need to do that before I get down to the nitty-gritty of the real design, real implementation and real details, so I need some rule of thumb to let me give broad ROM estimates.

One of our major customers recently asked for a feature and my sales colleague asked how long it would take. We didn't really know what the customer thought they wanted, so I went into a huddle with my lead programmer and together we sketched a reasonable feature that seemed to match the requirement, and estimated about 4 days of actual coding. I went back and replied that it would be 5 weeks of work on this feature (4 x 6 days) and that, given other commitments, that would be about 3 months elapsed time (one programmer working 1/2 time). So that's 5 weeks NRE on this feature, 3 months to delivery.

The feature was priced accordingly, and when the customer upped the priority we put a programmer on it full time. It was delivered to site and signed off 6 weeeks later.

Sometimes you need to estimate.

So, what was your point?

ADDED IN EDIT: I am, by the way, quite serious about that question. For me, in my circumstances, I really, really need to estimate in broad outline and get it roughly right. I'd like to see a clear exposition of why you think what I do is wrong. Could you perhaps write a more considered piece on your blog and link to it?

Re:Tell HN: My rule of thumb for initial estimation by briandoll on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @10:56PM (#1651656)
I agree that this is a very good topic and I'll flesh out some thoughts and post them soon. I'll email you when it's up. Would love to continue the dialog!