People on the Keynes side of the equation also get wound up over mentions of Chicago School stuff.
That said, it is weird that you're saying Krugman is some sort of government designated expert when almost every column he writes is critical of the economic policies being made in Washington. He disagreed with the size of the stimulus (he wanted it to be larger), he thinks the Fed has its head in the sand, etc. . . .
And as far as Paul Krugman being an expert, I find it very strange that you would disagree with that. You might disagree with his policy positions but he is most definitely an expert in the field.
Notice I never made any judgements about policy itself. My remark was that people who are not qualified in economics dismiss people who are right out of hand: Krugman is just a good example because he really seems to rile up libertarians and Austrians.
Personally my favourite opposing viewpoints to Krugman are made by Tyler Cowan, I like to read them both. Anyway, it's not my objective to get into a policy discussion, I was interested more in the meta-observation which you so handily provided reinforcement for.
We're talking about the problem of recovering from a leverage based bubble, an area where Ben "Helicopter" Bernanke (Chairman of The Fed) is an expert. If you look at what Wikipedia cites for Krugman's areas of specialty, they will touch on some of the issues of this but they don't seem to be directly related: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Krugman
That doesn't mean he's right (any or) all the time but it does mean that his opinions, even when wrong usually have a strong basis in established research. I'm using it in the same way that I'd say Bernanke, Paulson, Tyler Cowan, Greg Mankiw, etc. . . are experts.
The thing is that I find myself charged up over the topic as well, which makes me wonder why exactly it's such a hotpoint issue, and why it makes people (myself included) feel like they are qualified in a field in which they are clearly not. I mean that in the sense that I (nor, likely you) have any formal economics education beyond reading columns, articles, and perhaps attending econ 101 many years ago.
Edit to ad: This is not meant as a characterization of you, or an attack, etc. It is food for thought. You think that I was not "adding to the discussion" so, I've attempted to construct as neutral of a point as possible.
I think there's something about the seeming simplicity of the topic that appeals to programmers especially. We tend to be smarter than average and have mastered a field that involves a large amount of self-study. The inner narrative is then "I'm an expert" and somehow that really kicks in when we start talking about economics.
This is because much of what passes for economics is rationalizations given with a political purpose, and the primary propagandist in that effort is krugman. Remember. This is the guy who advocated that we should have a housing bubble, the denied we were in one, etc.
He is, to be sincere, and embarrassment to the science of economics.... But he is the government designated esparto and so there are millions of people who believe his nonsense because they don't know better and trust the experts.
Actually, the science of economics isn't that hard, nor is it complicated enough to need ot listen to an expert. You can teach yourself. Economics in one lesson is the tittle of a book that im sure you will find enlightening.... And it was written by an expert.