Re:U.S. considers adding nuclear cruise missiles to destroye...
by mikeash on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:15AM
(#16473058)
Our response to 9/11 was to invade two countries, one of which wasn’t even involved. I’m pretty sure that even a small nuke detonating on American territory would be met with the complete destruction of the attackers. We don’t really have the concept of a proportional response for this sort of thing.
Re:U.S. considers adding nuclear cruise missiles to destroye...
by michaelt on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:12AM
(#16473043)
they could use a small nuke against the US and we
wouldn't retaliate because we only have
overwhelmingly large nuclear weapons.
Given that America could simply fire a large nuclear weapon at a low-population-density area if they wanted a controlled number of deaths, no rational person would gamble their family's life on that.
Re:U.S. considers adding nuclear cruise missiles to destroye...
by duggan on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @07:54AM
(#16472931)
The logic would presumably be that using a significantly larger missile constitutes escalation rather than retaliation. Which begets escalation, which begets mutually assured destruction.
Game theory, rather than rhetoric.
NPR also asserted that there is a feeling among Russians (?) that they could use a small nuke against the US and we wouldn't retaliate because we only have overwhelmingly large nuclear weapons.
I don't know what the basis is for the claim of non-retaliation though NPR isn't necessarily known as some sort of portal of nationalist rhetoric so I'm left confused by the report.