News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diaspora doesn’t have what it takes to topple Facebook by Anon84 on Monday August 30, 2010 @11:14AM (#1646406)

    "The two major points of differentiation between Diaspora and Facebook are 
    1) Diaspora gives you more intuitive and effective control of your data privacy settings and 
    2) Diaspora is self-hosted, so you ultimately control all your own data.

    According to the blogosphere, these two points are precisely
    what the public is crying for and the exact recipe 
    necessary to finally break Facebook’s nefarious deathgrip on
    social networking. This, alas, is the social media/tech-blog
    echo chamber once again confusing its own desires with what
    the general public wants. "
This is the main point of the article. And, IMHO, the reason why projects like Diaspora are doomed to fail. For the general public, convenience will always trump privacy. If it's not easy to use, it's not used.

How many "normal" users encrypt their emails?

How many set an Administrator and User accounts on their windows machines?

Etc...

Re:Diaspora doesn’t have what it takes to topple Facebook by noodle on Monday August 30, 2010 @11:22AM (#1646433)
how many members of the general public even know what encrypted emails or admin/user accounts do for them? or even know that those things exist?

i think i'd make the argument that it could be successful because of the publicity of the product educating the public.

edit: really? downvoted? i had to talk someone through the concept of a "password" the other day. average people just don't know about granular privacy/security concepts.