Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by tetrazine on Monday February 26, 2018 @12:57AM
(#16463447)
Very interesting answer from Suzanne Sadedin. Very odd that "Arush Kakkar, Founder, CorsecoTech", who appears to neither be a physician, nor a medical science expert, nor a woman, is the highest displayed answer for me, with a strained analogy relating women's bodies to software, which is based on Suzanne's answer. I don't know if this is because of user voting, his score, or the Quora algorithm. I wonder if the mysteries of this ranking system are what lies behind the Quora login wall.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by elil17 on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:07AM
(#16463485)
Sadedin's post has over 20k upvotes, but that guy has 81. Definitely not because of user voting.
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by nostrademons on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:09AM
(#16463686)
It's fallen to #2 now. I would bet it's recency bias; that guy is probably there from this Hacker News link, made a follow-up answer, and because Quora (like HN and many forums) tends to put new replies at the top to give them a chance & see how they do with voting, it momentarily showed up as the top answer.
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by raldi on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:43AM
(#16463800)
Quite the opposite; his answer was from Jan 2015; the good answer arrived nearly two years later.
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by nostrademons on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:53AM
(#16463833)
I'm not terribly familiar with Quora's UI, but it looked like that's the date that the person's author profile was last updated, not the date that they answered the question. I could be totally wrong on this though. It's not possible for the good answer to have arrived later, because the bad answer references it (unless he edited the post afterwards to refer to it, but if the date on the post is actually a last-edit date for the post, that still wouldn't make sense).
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by raldi on Monday February 26, 2018 @08:51AM
(#16465206)
Oh, I think you’re right.
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by Simon_says on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:38AM
(#16463585)
His answer is kinda crap, to boot. Menopause isn't triggered by the number of menstrual cycles, but by age.
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by AstralStorm on Monday February 26, 2018 @04:05AM
(#16464076)
How do you know that? It is and a cop out answer because age is not a mechanism. Specifics please?
Re:Why can’t women get pregnant without the menstrual cycle?...
by Simon_says on Monday February 26, 2018 @09:39PM
(#16470715)
I apologize. It turns out my intuition was wrong about this. I just assumed that menopause was triggered by age, and I was going to look for evidence that age of menopause doesn't correlate with number of pregnancies, but it turns out it does! Childless women hit menopause earlier, on average. So, I guess I don't know.