News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The American Relief Expedition to Soviet Russia in the Fa... by Tech-Noir on Saturday February 24, 2018 @06:37AM (#16452842)
> You may want to stop arguing about your fantasies and try talking about something that has basis in actual history.

You may want to start taking your own advice. Try here first:

https://www.google.com/search?q=operation+barbarossa

> It is very much uncertain if the numbers would be much different.

No, it's extremely certain the numbers would be very different, since we know what the Nazis had planned for Eastern and Central Europe. So when you've finished with the above link, move on to this one:

https://www.google.com/search?q=generalplan+ost

> arguments are only about by how much exactly

Each author, by pulling a different number out of thin air, is saying the other author of the same book is wrong. Which would be laughable if some people didn't pretend take such nonsense seriously.

I say "pretend" because I don't believe for one second anyone using those numbers sincerely believes them, any more than they sincerely care about any of the actual, genuine victims beyond using them to score political points.

> Are you going to play the well-tired card of "but Stalin (Mao, etc. etc.) were not real, proper communists?

No, I'm going to say, again, that if someone wasn't killed by Communism they should not be counted as being killed by Communism.

What's interesting is that most of the victims of Stalin's purges were "proper Communists", a fact that right-wingers who cry crocodile tears over them always forget to mention for some reason.

> Taking the last grain, including seed grain, from, peasants (e.g. Prodrazverstka [...] is exactly that -- forced famine.

Prodrazverstka is not at all that:

    Bolsheviks borrowed the idea from the grain razvyorstka
    introduced in the Russian Empire during World War I, in 1916.

    [In 1918] the reserves of grain ran low, causing hunger among
    the urban population [...] In order to satisfy minimal food
    needs, the Soviet government introduced strict control over the
    food surpluses of the prosperous rural households.  

    Lenin believed that prodrazvyorstka was the only possible way
    to procure sufficient amounts of grain and other agricultural
    products for the population of the cities during the civil war.

    Prodrazvyorstka allowed the Soviet government to solve the
    important problem of supplying the [...] urban population
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prodrazvyorstka

> No, should I?

Then why accept any of the different numbers, that the authors themselves can't even agree are accurate, in the Black Book of Communism?

> (sigh)

If you're Jewish then just say so; don't imply it, whether it's true or not, to try and score points in an argument.

Re:The American Relief Expedition to Soviet Russia in the Fa... by Fins on Sunday February 25, 2018 @02:27AM (#16457686)
1. Because these are the best numbers available for crimes of communists. And really, arguing whether communists killed 5 times as many people as nazis, or only 3 times as much might be an important discussion, but not in this context.

2. It should not matter. And really, I just do not want to associate with people who think it should.