News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by wmeredith on Friday February 23, 2018 @05:06PM (#16450040)
We either need more or less. If the ISP's government granted local monopolies were dissolved we wouldn't need net neutrality because the free market would do its job.
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by 13years on Friday February 23, 2018 @07:40PM (#16450887)
> ISP's government granted local monopolies

This really needed to be part of the public discourse. It is a component which received little attention. However, it is quite typical IMHO. Government creates a problem for itself to solve. Infinite recursion then ensues.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by 49531 on Friday February 23, 2018 @11:55PM (#16451758)
Meh, I like to think of it like my other utilities. They're, in a lot of cases, monopolies granted by government, but they seem to work fairly well in most places.

Allowing corporations to benefit from natural monopolies without regulating them is just a bad idea.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by philipov on Friday February 23, 2018 @07:53PM (#16450947)
If you're in the business of selling glass, go out and break some windows.
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by rectang on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:04PM (#16451197)
The "deregulation" of Ajit Pai's FCC is just picking winners. It's hands massive market advantage to an oligopoly of telecom companies at the expense of everyone else.

All markets are constructed. Markets constructed by self-professed "deregulators" seem to be particularly skewed and corrupt.

[dead]
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by shard972 on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:54PM (#16451362)
Can you explain how the people against internet regulations are uninformed? I feel that when we are talking about internet regulations the burden of proof must be on those arguing for the regulation.

So far I still haven't heard a great argument, it's all based around "well ISPs could do this in the future" and not based on things that are happening now.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by zenhack on Friday February 23, 2018 @11:16PM (#16451630)
This was posted to hackernews a couple months ago:

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/12/att-says-it-neve...

As the article points out the kind of abuses people are talking about are nit theoretical; they were done before the 2015 rules went into effect. This was especially true on mobile plans.

Another thing is you can look at how this has played out in other countries, and it isn't pretty. There's an image floating around of an ad for a Portuguese ISP, which looks like a cable tv add from the 90's -- explicit lists of sites that are provided.

It's hard to study this kind of phenomenon with the level of rigor we'd expect from a physicist. That sort of thing is kinda the best you can do.

Finally, I have friends who work at companies who do larger scale traffic analysis on the net, and from what they've told me, at least before the 2015 rules, throttling was basically the norm, though you'd be hard pressed to get the pr departments to admit it.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by patrickaljord on Saturday February 24, 2018 @08:00AM (#16453077)
> There's an image floating around of an ad for a Portuguese ISP, which looks like a cable tv add from the 90's -- explicit lists of sites that are provided.

And there's nothing wrong with this. What this picture floating around doesn't say is that the Portuguese ISP is for mobile and this ISP also provides a full internet access plan for mobile cheaper and faster than in the US. It is true that they also provide cheap plans limited to certain websites for people who can't afford the regular plan.

What liberals would want would have the consequence of people who can't afford the regular plan to not have any plans at all. My family in Peru run on similar cheap plans limited to Whatsapp, Facebook, Wikipedia and a few other services and thanks to this I can communicate with them. As usual, liberals principals for fairness would in reality punish the poor who would lose access to these services but at least liberals would sleep better at night knowing that no one is getting "cable tv from the 90's" like internet (whatever that means). Instead, they would get no internet at all. Well played folks.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by zenhack on Saturday February 24, 2018 @02:54PM (#16454990)
First, I'll point out that this is not a "liberal" thing; polling has revealed that republican voters are by and large for keeping the net neutrality rules as well. This isn't a left vs right issue, it's basically big ISPs vs most everyone else.

Second, and more to the point, internet service is generally much cheaper in other countries, but the reasons are most definitely not lack of regulations. It basically comes down to local monopolies, and the usual effects of lack of competition. Giving large ISPs more power will not help. This article gives a decent overview of the situation:

https://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/10/31/upshot/why-the-us-has-...

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by jakeogh on Friday February 23, 2018 @06:00PM (#16450391)
Ya, that's what the people you disagree with are... "uninformed" or "ISP shills". Brilliant!
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by s73v3r_ on Friday February 23, 2018 @07:26PM (#16450822)
When they make incorrect claims on what Net Neutrality is, or say blatantly false things that benefit the telcoms, then you can't blame one for thinking that those people are shilling.
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by jakeogh on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:52PM (#16451352)
Like? It's trivially true that "Net Neutrality" adds regulation.
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by pas on Saturday February 24, 2018 @05:32AM (#16452652)
You mix proximate and ultimate purposes/causes. Mozilla wants a free internet, that's the ultimate purpose, but considering all the current social, political, and economical reality, its proximate purpose is to oppose the FCC's change in regulation.

Arguing that somehow Mozilla "fights for", as in ultimately wants the amount of regulatory burden to grow, for its own sake, it foolish and ignorant at best, but very much seems like a bad faith argument.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by jakeogh on Saturday February 24, 2018 @04:33PM (#16455546)
"foolish and ignorant" you really cant help it can you? The mental contortions necessary to pretend such a simple to verify statement is not true are shockingly common.

Yes, Mozilla is "fighting for" (aka spending time and resources on) _adding_ regulation to the internet.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by pas on Sunday February 25, 2018 @09:42AM (#16459148)
They don't spend time and resources to "add regulation", they spend resources to have an open Internet.

Currently the path toward that is doing something against browser monoculture and doing something about the actions of the new FCC.

The FCC changed to a different regulatory regime, which is inadequate, hence Mozilla tries to get back to the previous one.

You can try to measure up regulation with some kind of one-dimensional measure, and claim that Mozilla wants "more", but that's completely missing the point.

You can also say that Mozilla would not be okay with a totally unregulated Internet, because it'd take decades for the ISP market to solve the short term problems, that doesn't mean they wouldn't like a plan that phases out regulation where markets are healthy.

Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by s73v3r_ on Friday February 23, 2018 @05:50PM (#16450321)
Yup. Regulations to make things better for their, and all Internet users.
Re:Mozilla Re-Files Suit Against FCC to Protect Net Neutrality by azdle on Friday February 23, 2018 @05:05PM (#16450036)
Yeah, it is wonderful, isn't it?