News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by tristanj on Thursday February 22, 2018 @10:09PM (#16443885)
This article is missing the key part where China blocked and limited products by major foreign tech giants such as Google, Facebook, Microsoft et al so homegrown Chinese variants could flourish.
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by Arn_Thor on Friday February 23, 2018 @04:23AM (#16445198)
The classic 'East Asian growth model' tactic. It's classic because it works, almost every time
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by intended on Friday February 23, 2018 @06:41AM (#16445707)
Also its not like the west managed its growth solely out of the strength of their intellect and labor.

It seems that all major ladders to the top have some dark rungs the victors are happy to hide when they reach the top.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by coldtea on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:33AM (#16446484)
If brands like Google, Facebook, Microsoft et al were Chinese owned and controlled, the US would have done much of the same.

Only third and fourth tier players (like what the European countries have become now) let others control such key infrastructure.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by tinyrick2 on Friday February 23, 2018 @07:05AM (#16445804)
Don't you think that by limiting foreign companies' products the local companies would operate less efficiently since there is no competition? I think I was taught about this in my econ 101 class. Why does it work differently this time?
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by coldtea on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:41AM (#16446523)
Several factors.

(1) Econ 101 classes mostly sell students an idealized version of economy.

(2) Top-tier countries have used all kinds of techniques (protectionism, tariffs, etc) to get successful, but now that they don't need those anymore, they pay lip service to the Econ 101 "laws" that are against those same techniques.

(3) While clothed in scientific parlance, a lot of what is Econ 101 is just BS to promote the interests of those in power, not what's best for the people in general (that's how an ecomomics professor gets grants, becomes policy advisor, etc).

The scientific part is just using some math while still basing their ideas on idealized unworkable models and unprovable assumptions.

That said, even if all the above was not true, the internal market in China is 1.6 billion people. 4-5 times the US is more than enough to have lots of internal competition.

Heck, there are US-only brands the rest of the world doesn't care at all about -- and that's on a 350 million people market, and they still do just fine.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by ttoinou on Friday February 23, 2018 @10:52AM (#16447041)

   The scientific part is just using some math while still basing their ideas on idealized unworkable models and unprovable assumptions.
You don't need maths to show that less competition changes the incentive to the point that it could bring down quality of service.
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by coldtea on Friday February 23, 2018 @11:19AM (#16447240)
Yes, but also don't need maths to know that competition can be controlled with 20 ways (and usually is, e.g. US ISPs), or that you can have tariffs AND internal competition.

Or even that you can have a fine quality product at a good price even without competition at all -- e.g. produced by a single vendor, as long as the vendor is so inclined.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by ttoinou on Friday February 23, 2018 @11:30AM (#16447327)
If competition is controlled then there's less competition and one can expect efficiency to drop down ceteris paribus. Now you have to explain why controlling competition could lead into better quality or cheaper prices. (The only thing I see is that it could let governments keep more money, thus more power ?)

  fine quality product at a good price even without competition at all 
Threat of competition is also a form of competition (for example a software product not protected with patents, anyone could compete so the producer offers good prices)
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by Can_Not on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:49PM (#16451344)
The US is really big, if there's not a mis-configured regulation, adding overseas competition won't really increase efficiency as the perfectly sperical market in a vacuum equation suggests.
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by ttoinou on Friday February 23, 2018 @11:05PM (#16451597)
Maths have nothing to do with economics. I said efficiency as a way of comparing market offer from the point of view of customers (you can picture the formula "quality/price" if you want but that doesn't mean that it is objectively & mathematically defined), meaning that prices go down and/or quality increases

   mis-configured regulation
Do you have examples of good protectionist regulation ?

And no I gave a specific example with software patents so even if the US is big enough it can benefits from outside products

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by Can_Not on Saturday February 24, 2018 @09:29AM (#16453352)
If we're talking about efficiency from the customer point of view, I can pay full price for American goods on Amazon but receive garbage-cheap Chinese knock-offs in the mail.
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by ttoinou on Sunday February 25, 2018 @09:58AM (#16459222)
I don't even understand what you are trying to prove. That some sellers are not trust worthy ? That there will always be an intermediary taking the profit ?
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by dogma1138 on Friday February 23, 2018 @08:20AM (#16446116)
Not necessarily the same things happened also in Russia.

Competition can still happen just locally and while competition is good when the scale is unbalanced it can be just as bad or worse than no competition at all.

Almost no one is developing a Google search competitor because it’s near impossible to do so while people have access to Google the need isn’t there and you can’t compete unless you are actually better there isn’t as much niche to search as people think. You also have the problem of resource imbalance where Google can just go and buy out the local competition at ease due to their wealth this what has happened with dating and P2P commerce sites all over the world.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by RobertoG on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:26AM (#16446449)
You can't develop an industry from nothing without protection. This is how happened in the USA, protecting nascent industries from others (the UK mainly). It seems that the Chinese are very aware of this historic truth.

The corollary being that, if you are already a developed country, and you want to avoid competition, a good way to do it would be to force, other countries, to "open they markets".

A good book about the subject: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/187808.Kicking_Away_the_...

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by tqkxzugoaupvwqr on Friday February 23, 2018 @08:04AM (#16446042)
> Don't you think that by limiting foreign companies' products the local companies would operate less efficiently since there is no competition?

There is no foreign competition but Chinese companies still have competition from other Chinese companies.

Even if the Chinese market is less efficient because competition is limited to China: The goal is to foster a healthy national economy, create knowledge, and most importantly keep total control over technologies and communication channels.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 23, 2018 @07:37AM (#16445933)
No, it’s still true. Chinese companies in protected industries are as inefficient as expected.
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by coldtea on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:42AM (#16446533)
Really, Weibo, TaiBao, Alibaba and co are "inefficient"?
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:53AM (#16446599)
Taibao and Alibaba aren’t really protected. As for Tencent, look at its success in other countries when competing against google and Facebook....
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by aikinai on Thursday February 22, 2018 @10:53PM (#16444073)
When I first saw the headline, that’s specifically what I assumed it would be about!
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by yadongwen on Friday February 23, 2018 @12:16AM (#16444402)
Google, M$ and Amazon were not successful when they were not blocked in China.. Amazon China is still not blocked but far behind JD, Alibaba, etc. In some areas like fintech, drones, consumer apps and games China is clearly the leader. If FB is unblocked I doubt it can compete with Tencent at all. Tencent has a higher market cap than FB and understands the Chinese so much more..
Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by Zafira on Friday February 23, 2018 @12:30AM (#16444440)
I don't think this concedes how much a factor Chinese regionalism plays into the dominance of Chinese companies in China. The government has had a much stronger hand in shaping what technologies and companies flourish than in the rest of the developed world. How the market would have looked if the government was less heavy-handed is an open question, but I think it is misleading to omit this factor.

Also, there are things that foreign companies simply will not concede to Beijing. Tencent allows full access to their networks to the government. Ephemeral criticisms of the government can get you a warning from the state. This is unconscionable behavior in a lot of other countries, but it's a concession Chinese companies have made time and again.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by kochthesecond on Friday February 23, 2018 @02:56AM (#16444892)
Well, I did not know that.

Are there any sources where I can read more? I know Google fought a lot over similar issues and eventually withdrew their hardware from China.

Also, the Chinese are building a citizen scoring card system, that will rate your standing with the government from birth to death.

Re:From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech sup... by ghostcluster on Friday February 23, 2018 @01:01AM (#16444558)
> In some areas like fintech, drones, consumer apps and games China is clearly the leader

Maybe vaping/e-cigarette technology too.

> BIS Research estimates that the global electronic cigarette industry will exhibit a growth of over 22.36% (CAGR) from 2015 to 2025, to reach a total market value of $50 Billion by 2025

https://bisresearch.com/industry-report/electronic-cigarette...