If I was allowed to make one change on HN it would be that a downvote had to be accompanied by a comment as to why the downvote happens.
You make it sound like voting-as-disagreement is rare but in my experience it's by far the most common way downvotes are used. I have showdead switched on and I keep toying with the idea of finding an extension to un-grey comments, because over and over I find comments in grey that are well written, erudite and merely express an opinion that goes against the current startup-culture HN zeitgeist. They aren't actually bad comments though.
So why not just let good comments rise to the top.
https://userstyles.org/styles/156181/hacker-news-improved-re...
If you had a user style extension you could just change the five styles used to grey out down-voted and dead comments.
Perhaps yeah abolish downvote and only have flag for admins and people with high karma is a good idea.