Bitcoin is 10 years old... hardly the "early days" in tech.
Of course, digital cash has been worked on for many years too, but if you compare the bitcoin whitepaper to, say, the TCP/IP RFC, then you'd expect AOL-comparable bitcoin usage in 2030, more or less.
I agree that current crypto-currency ecosystems are pretty insane, but the original idea was super-cool.
It doesn't really seem we are moving in that direction. While more people know about bitcoin and more people own bitcoin, it seems like the number of people willing to transact in it has made no progress.
> It's like asking if the goals of the Internet are dead because most people log-in via AOL and browse only AOL curated content.
Arguably, the original goals and design of the Internet ARE dead (or not dead, but certainly not dominant or ascendant). While the AOL business model may have failed, similar closed systems have dominated most of the content and use of the internet. The number of people who build their own sites on any topic or even publish blogs vs. the number of people who post to Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat is pretty tiny. Open federated chat clients have been mostly replace by closed, proprietary systems.
> The above could all fail; I'm not saying it _will_ happen. Just that it's too early to declare the original vision dead.
While it may be too early to declare it dead. Your analogy to the internet seems like a strong argument to be concerned that the vision is dying.
I'd say in some cases there have been regressions. Many indie-type groups have stopped accepting Bitcoin due to its volatility and high transaction fees. Stripe has announced its support for Bitcoin will end late April.
Certainly there's the possibility that things will calm down and it will bounce back, but personally I'm pretty bearish.
Crypto adoption is still at a very low percentage in the United States. Imagine one day when _most_ people own crypto, and are willing to transact in it, and there is more advanced tooling and software and understanding. What will the world look like then?
As a specific example, take a look at the 0x protocol, and the many relayers that are building on top of it like Radar Relay or Dy/Dx. 0x and these companies are tying to build exchanges that let you trade alts with zero counter-party risk. The trade occurs via on-chain smart contracts.
The above could all fail; I'm not saying it _will_ happen. Just that it's too early to declare the original vision dead.
And as sibling commentators have noted, even today one can easily send BTC peer-to-peer once you have some without any intermediaries.