I don't have any problem with the idea that folks don't need semi automatic assault rifles. But that is mostly not the framing I am hearing when gun control is mentioned and it appalls me to hear the argument you are making that someone victimized like you were should simply be deprived of a means to fight back and that is something good.
I am incredibly uncomfortable with the argument you are making. My dad was career military and I grew up with guns in the house. Having guns does not cause people to go postal. We need to stop being okay with a culture that routinely gives people a reason to go postal.
That doesn't happen overnight because of a single ugly incident. It is the outgrowth of years of things going wrong. And we should not be okay with that and taking the position that bullying is fine as long as the victim can't get an assault rifle.
One of the problems with the focus on gun control is that the shooters were typically bullied. So when you say:
You don't try to preach civilisation to your attacker, you block the person attacking you first,
You are very selectively deciding who the victim is here and you are also being a hypocrite. Your approach is actually very in line with that of the people who go postal because they have concluded there is no peaceful answer and they just need to pit a stop to their bullies.
I see this as incredibly problematic and as turning a blind eye to the real problem. I have every reason to believe that the focus on gun control actually undermines the pursuit of a real remedy. Because it says what was done to the shooter that made them go postal is fine. In fact, it tends to become a justification after the fact for the bullying because the media and the world at large talk about it like it is just this one mentally unstable guy who behaved really badly.
I get attacked for wanting to talk about the root cause here. I get decried as being a sympathizer with the shooter.
So when we focus on gun control is The Answer, we don't stop and question that narrative. In fact, we validate it.
In the far east, when governments forbade peasants from owning weapons, the invented martial arts to turn their hands, feet and farm implements into deadly force. If you don't remedy the root cause, the bullied kids who want revenge will just need to get more creative. This can be worse.
One of the reasons it can be worse: the handling of these cases sends a message to all the other bullied misfits that after society has spent years failing to protect you from torture, we are going to make you out to be the bad guy and send you to prison. So it just spreads the idea that you are fucked anyway and no one will ever care about your side of things and there is no hope for you, so you might as well take out as many as you can as the only message you can send the world that bullying the misfits is not okay and if you choose to be a bully you better watch your back.
The focus on gun control here is a focus on the wrong thing. It is a position of the beatings shall continue until morale improves.
I have already said I am not for letting people have assault weapons. But both replies to my comment ignored that fact to argue with me. Most of the discussion I am seeing about gun control is de facto going a lot further than addressing assault weapons. I am seeing zero discussion about "What the hell went wrong in this kid's life that it got to this point?" The president and media are both characterizing him as a disturbed nutcase.
I raised two difficult children. One has most of the personality traits of your typical serial killer. The other has a violent temper. Neither has assaulted anyone, in part because I pulled them out of a horrifying school system full of bullies and asshole teachers and administrators who did not care and I homeschooled. Watching my son come home from school in tears every day while the system did nothing to help was not acceptable to me.
So I have firsthand experience with how you prevent an outcome like this. And it starts by expecting civilized treatment of the difficult kids.
My oldest was having fantasies of driving a tank through the school when I pulled him out, a thing I only learned years later. His father had the keys to a military motor pool full of Bradley fighting vehicles. I am sure that for an angry adolescent, that would have been close enough to a tank to satisfy him.
To me, there is nothing hypothetical about what I am saying. We rise up as a nation and decide the bullying must stop or we continue to see variations on these incidents. If you take the guns and don't stop the torture of the misfit kids, then all you have done is change the mechanism by which they go postal and the conversation becomes "how do we stop the bombs/tanks/whatever?"
My example was intended to illustrate that discussion can only come when active, physical violence ceases.
And I am telling you the active physical violence precedes these incidents and I want that to stop. Characterizing the shooting as the entirety of the violence is part of the problem.
That's not what I said or even implied. Of course we need to foster an environment that prevents bullying in the first place too. Doesn't mean we don't need common sense gun control like every other democracy has done that doesn't have the sort of problems with gun violence we have.
Furthermore, this constant barrage of specious anecdata of "I grew up with guns and there were no problems" flies in the face of what we know about households with guns statistically. You're far, far, far more likely to be killed with your own gun than to defend yourself lethally with it.
Statistics don't support what you're saying:
https://crimeresearch.org/2015/06/comparing-death-rates-from...
nickbauman says>"You're far, far, far more likely to be killed with your own gun than to defend yourself lethally with it."
The chance that you need to shoot someone to defend yourself, your family or your property or someone else's property is thankfully minuscule. And it is true that owning a weapon of any kind increases the risk of misuse (hence the need for proper education). But how about cases where a weapon was used to defend oneself or break off the attack?
Statistics aren't collected on such encounters.
To quote Archie Bunker: "Would you be happier if they were pushed out of windows?"
Murder predated the existence of guns. Locking up all guns won't make murder stop.
At what point do we address the roots of such problems?
"For every man chopping at the roots of evil, there are a thousand chopping at the branches."
why not start with eliminating the means of going "postal"? Why even have a "right" to AR15s or any guns at all.
These school shooters aren't targeting their tormentors. This most recent shooting involved a 19-year-old former student.
The Sandy Hook shooter killed defenseless elementary schoolers.
> toxic masculinity
What exactly does this mean? Seems like an attack on masculinity as a whole, because it's a poorly defined pejorative that focuses on men.
The point is to assert that these behaviors are both optional and destructive to teach to just one sex. A constructive human ideal should be taught to everyone, ignoring sex like one would ignore race or shoe size or other physical property.
If you can't see through the rhetorical bent of the term "toxic masculinity," then I will try to show you how I see it. To argue that this isn't an attack on masculinity, let's replace the noun only. It's like saying "toxic communism" but arguing that the phrase is not an attack on communism.
Are you saying there is a special, clearly defined sort of masculinity that is toxic, yet extricable from masculinity itself? That's a tall order.
I mean, whether or not the lines can be cleanly drawn, there is quite obviously a divide. Think humble family man vs. aggressive jock. (Or, if you’re Christian, Jesus is a perfect example of non-toxic masculinity.) Unfortunately, we often seem to glorify the toxic kind in our media: warriors, gangsters, womanizers. Also, there are plenty of cultures around the world that do masculinity very differently than we in the West — and it has little to do with relative levels of testosterone.
I think it’s also disingenuous to say that toxic masculinity poorly defined. It’s not a buzzword, but an entire subfield of sociology that has years of research behind it.
Like you, I was mercilessly bullied for years - up until fifth grade. At some point while being beaten by one of the larger ones, something snapped inside my mind, and I ended up chasing him down and slamming his face into the basketball court until teachers pulled me off.
I was never bullied again. All because I finally exercised what all boys need to exercise: raw aggression in defense of person. It is the only language bullies ever understand.
You don’t trust yourself and can not trust others. I wish this was uncommon, but it’s not.
I guess I wonder what you think two weeks of formal firearm training in academy does to police to grant them magical self control?
nickbauman>"Because they were, to any point of rationality, on a direct course to killing me. I felt like it was me or them."
"To any point of rationality"?? "...me or them"??
Well, you're alive, aren't you? The idea that you thought of killing/shooting someone indicates that you were socially isolated to an extreme degree. Where were your parents, your brothers and sisters, your friends? Did you have any?
And now you're still angry and, sadly, screwed up. Your anger toward your old bullies has been redirected toward responsible gun owners. Now you'll punish those old bullies by supporting "common sense gun control".
you got issues, mate. maybe talk to someone?
> We need common sense gun control.
like what? anything short of repealing the 2A makes no sense to me frankly. Perhaps it's time to just repeal it and possibly confiscate guns across the board.
No, the school/community he was at had issues. They didn't take bullying seriously, did nothing to prevent it and did nothing to punish it when it went too far.
It's the same here in Norway, a couple of kids committed suicide because of bullying, that got a lot of media coverage, but the situation doesn't seem to have changed. Politicians are still arguing about "what to do with bullies" and how to force them to change schools.
... And since Norway is unaccustomed to violence, I thought for long for myself that nothing's going to change until some bullied kid decides to take other's lives instead of his/her own.
but that definitely has left some psychological issues in him/her and so its definitely worth talking to someone, a professional, about this. People with suicidal / homicidal tendencies should definitely seek out help.
Get ready for a civil war then, because the US country side will not let the cities get their guns.
Some even seems to take pride in how they can't even talk reasonably to their relatives once a year.
People notice this and might not be very keen on cooperating with people who despise them.
Also maybe they've read history and knows what happens to unpopular unarmed people.
Unfortunately, many in the country seem to feel that America is White and Christian, and that’s just not a viewpoint that can be easily reconciled with more cosmopolitan city folks.
you are right. Maybe I should have mentioned. My intention was not to single out anyone but to talk to the people who actually attend HN.
I get it though. My folks are from a village in India. We sometimes get shit on by city folks too. Some country folks like guns. But its not a "right".
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Amendment_to_the_Unit...
If its not a right, then the government can pass much stronger gun laws, including confiscations, etc. But still allows good citizens to own guns for hunting and stuff. Maybe even limit the number of guns per person, control the type of gun, etc. Just give enough so that country folks are happy with simple hunting rifles and cant do much damage.
The semantics are important because it illuminates the philosophy of rights and the Constitution, and perhaps that illumination may help you to understand how many people see it differently.
Right now they cannot because the constitution doesn't allow it. If you repeal 2A, then they (Congress) will be able to do much more about guns.
The Constitution is written from the opposite direction, that all power lies in the people and the Constitution is the mechanism by which we grant limited authority to the government. In fact, this was a big part of the debate around passing the Bill of Rights in the first place, that it would confuse this issue. Repealing the 1st Amendment would not remove our right to free speech. It would simply remove the codification of that right and we would revert to natural law which still would include free speech. In order for the government to infringe on our natural right to free speech we the people would have to pass an amendment explicitly granting the government the authority to do so. The same of course applies to the 2A.
This is essentially the philosophy of the founders and the limited government crowd you're going to be arguing against if you want to regulate guns.
I'm hoping that you'll see that this isn't just a semantic difference in the mechanism by which you might accomplish gun restrictions, but a deeper difference in the belief system around the philosophy of law. I'm not trying to change your mind about the 2A here, but to help you relate to the small government crowd with the way you talk about the law. You're not trying to revert a power granted to us by the government, you're trying to subvert natural law.
We have given up our natural right to kill another person. I am suggesting we should give up our natrual right to bear arms.
The idea with natural rights has always been that we have unlimited rights (and actually enumerating them can be problematic) but we give some up to live in a society where we can pursue life liberty and happiness.
I am saying Americans via their representatives should give up their right to bear arms, remove it from being enumerated, and then allow strong legislation that outlaws weapons just like we have done with murder. If an amendment is needed then so be it "Congress HAS the right to strictly control guns in order to protect life".
Does that make sense?
Yes, they are.
> The founders believed rights were natural.
They may have had a moral belief that certain rights were natural, and that may have been the basis for them incorporating the rights into the Constitution, but moral beliefs are not the same thing as material facts.
"We the people of the United States... do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America"
All powers, including the power to establish the Constitution in the first place, are derived from the people.
Section 8 explicitly lays out which powers we the people are granting to the government: borrow money, regulate commerce with foreign nations, establish a post office, etc.
If powers are not explicitly granted to the government, it doesn't have them.
A little nitpicking: in US it is actually a right.
It might seem weird for the rest of us but then again in their defense they never had a Srebrenica, an Auswich, a Rwanda in the last century so I guess it can be seen as an insurance:
They're paying a few lives every year to protect against genocides.
(And to be perfectly clear: I don't want that system here where I live, I just try to understand their situation.)
I see what you are getting at. But honestly, if the gov wants to do a genocide, they have tanks and bombers to do it. No AR15 will help against that anyway.
To control a population you need boots on the ground.
This is such an odd statement. The time is past, the actions have occurred; they cannot be redone. All that remains are your memories and emotions, which can be changed.
Everyone is different and no two people handle a situation in the same way.
Its too bad that you were unable to get good advice and/or consolation at the time. But maybe, with some counseling, or discussion with friends, you can revisit this bad experience and others and change how you feel about them and yourself.
Please, talk to someone (like a consuelor or a therapist) and work it out.
Bullies do exist. Sometimes, they teach you something, and sometimes they're just bullies. (I'm not excusing their behavior).
Isn't it good that you didn't have access to guns? So why not just repeal the 2A?
Teaching gun culture and demanding gun safes (like it's done around here) would probably be a safer and more efficient route.
That can be done and the 2A can also be repealed (gun ownership doesnt need to be a "right"). Why not do both?
I'm sure what's left of the government will act in the best interest of the entire country.
And surely all the guns will just cease to exist after our right to legally bear them is repealed. Gangsters, teenage boys, drug dealers, they will all happily turn in their guns and promise not to get any more.
If it wasn't a right then it would suddenly be worthless in many districts.
Here's some middle ground:
Mandatory training. Around here it is provided by hunters organizations, often at cost price.
Background checks by police + recommendation by hunter organization or the equivalent of NRA.
The only reason I didn't become a school shooter is because I literally did not know how to get a gun. I didn't live in a community where there was any kind of gun culture. That's all. If I would have had access to a gun I would have tried to kill them. Because they were, to any point of rationality, on a direct course to killing me. I felt like it was me or them.
I am the school shooter poster child for gun control. Because I couldn't get a gun, I survived my ordeal and became a productive member of society. We need common sense gun control.