No, you want some sort of structure where you have people you trust do some sorting. That's what the publishing system does. (Plus the editing process).
Elsevier is earning money because they have created a structure of evaluation that's not entirely garbage, and that is self-reinforcing. It might be good to replace them with a non-profit approach, but isn't easy.
Elsevier doesn't read or evaluate them either. They use academic peer reviewers who don't have any equity or salary from Elsevier.
> No, you want some sort of structure where you have people you trust do some sorting.
None of those people are paid by Elsevier.
> That's what the publishing system does. (Plus the editing process).
No, the publishing system provides brands. If Elsevier actually curated, hired and paid a fair salary to the peer reviewers and researchers who actually performed and evaluate the research I think you would be right. But it still seems to me they're purely a marketing middleman that takes public funding and public laborers and turns a private profit.
If this is true it reflects poorly on academia and science (insofar as science is an organized activity). Shouldn’t research be judged by its own merits, and the results it produces against verifiable goals and not the popularity contest of competing journals? IMHO to the extent that what you are saying is true, it’s honestly understandable and a little justified that the public is skeptical of academic science. You’re saying it’s in large part a popularity contest.