I must say your argument resembles arguments in favor of the divine design. Specifically, I mean appealing to outstanding people as an argument. It is safe to state that effectively every outstanding creator before ~1870 had a deep faith in God and of course it affected her personality deeply. However I don't expect you to decide for yourself if God exists relying on this impressive statistics.
As for the link with mathematics, it is relevant to our discussion to mention here that I work in mathematical physics. To put it shortly, my work experience is that music has no special role in the research and definitely not in the understanding of it on the contrary to what you say. I can elaborate more if there were readers.
Let me repeat myself, I don't deny that music improves the quality of our life and can serve as an inspiration and improve the productivity as I experience it every day just like most of us. My point is different.
Hope to hear your feedback.
I believe you made two strong claims in your original post, the first being that music's "purpose" is to illicit some kind of psychological effect, perhaps in the fashion of a neurostimulant, and the second was that consuming music is not a "meaningful" activity. Your conclusion is that you find it a "waste of time" to "put conscious efforts to listen to more classical music and to educate themselves about it."
Would you mind elucidating a few things for me? What is your conception of purpose? Do you mean utility, use? Like a hammer or mathematical model? If so is not deriving relaxing states from music a use or utility? Does your conception of purpose carry ethical baggage? Does that explain why you chose the contentious extremes of drugs and sex to equate with music? If so, on what grounds should others adopt your conception of purpose and meaningfulness? Are those grounds objective?
Yes, mine are empirical, and to an extent subjective. What of it?
I assumed that making something of value for other people is what makes life meaningful. Making and shipping a product, supporting a family, writing poetry and producing music, doing research and participating in constructive discussions is meaningful for me. I assumed that some readers here share these values to some extent.
I didn't tell people what to do. I shared my view and am genuinely interested in your view on the subject. I tend to think that is why we are all here.
The way I see it is that we appreciate order, structure, logic, symmetry, yes? This is true for painting, drama, computing, nearly all art. I don't see why you make an exception for music. Maybe it's because it doesn't contain spoken language, or because it is abstract. I submit that any beauty you can derive from architecture, sculpture or industrial design, you can derive from music as well, for all of the reasons relating to the qualities I've outlined. The only difference, as you aptly put in your comparison to drugs and sex, is the "delivery mechanism" of the artistic content. Thus, I cannot see a reason to discriminate and single out listening to music as a waste of time.
I think that if more people appreciated the complexity and richness of classical music, chances are they would forgo other what I call cheap products in our world: bubblegum pop music, underdeveloped political arguments, and terribly unusable technology. Good music is on your side of intellectual achievement. Listening to and understanding good music is the mark of high artistic and intellectual standards, a good, positive willingness to explore and expand one's aesthetic horizons. I think the PRODUCT of this attitude, is far from, as you say, some kind of negative counterproductiveness, where time spent listening to music is time not spent doing science. The product of this kind of attitude is a high standard of achievement that is completely compatible with doing great science with passion and dedication. At least that's my view.
That's not to mention the fact that music ostensibly IS intertwined with our language and culture, so it would be almost impossible to relate to other people (or understand them, communicate with them, as is the project of numerous scientific fields) if we didn't share their practices. You'd be left in a very strange position of describing an "objective" reality devoid of the emotions that make humanness--and by extension, the world--what it is.
I recommend you engage in a deeper reading of science and objectivity, because nary will you find a thinker or scientist whose findings, motivations, or thought processes are completely uniformed by a particular set of aesthetic considerations. Theories are beautiful. Designs speak to us. Mathematical formulations must be true. These convictions are developed from the same stuff as that of our musical convictions. They are one and the same.