News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by uberman on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @11:25AM (#16430597)
You want your child to go to college because:

1) The average run of the mill degree results in twice the earnings and half the unemployment of those with just high school.

2) The average run of the mill degree results in a $900k lift in lifetime earnings (for men) over a high school diploma. The lift for women is not quite that much but that might have something to do with the types of degrees that each get.

These numbers are averages so if your child completes a stem degree from say MIT, the lift in lifetime earnings is likely quite a bit more than that.

Want more? Check out : https://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.htm

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by wojt_eu on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @11:46AM (#16430769)
This shows correlation but not causation. Hypothetically: people with certain background (social class) and traits (IQ) are more likely to go to college, and they would fare as well or better without college. I'd be very interested in stats of lifetime earnings difference that was corrected for selection bias.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by uberman on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @12:02PM (#16430895)
Would a 1% sample of the US population that included level of education and earnings do the trick for you?

https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/...

It is not going to have variables like "Social status of your parents" or "IQ" but it does have a rather extensive list of demographic variables to control for.

Let me know what you uncover.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by jessriedel on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @12:14PM (#16431013)
IQ, conscientiousness, and parental social status are probably the three biggest determiners of success, presumably none of which are being controlled for.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by the_watcher on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @12:53PM (#16431379)
Sample size doesn't impact the fact that you shouldn't draw causal conclusions from merely correlative data.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by uberman on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:33PM (#16431714)
Then perhaps you might want to check out some twins studies:

http://davidcard.berkeley.edu/papers/causal_educ_earnings.pd...

and/or

http://www.nytimes.com/1992/08/19/education/twins-study-show...

I'm going to strongly encourage my kids to go to college.

Frankly if you/anyone is not convinced that higher education leads to increased earnings then by all means forgo college and keep your kids at home.

My kids will have plenty of competition for jobs from those with higher degrees from around the world as it is.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by the_watcher on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:30PM (#16432209)
Pointing out that you should not draw causal conclusions from correlative data does not mean that I would not encourage my kids from going to college. It means that you should not conclude that going to any college causes better outcomes. It also doesn't mean that you should conclude that going to college does not cause better outcomes.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by uberman on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:17PM (#16432577)
I agree. In fact, I pointed out that the data set I referenced was unlikely to include items like "Parental Social Class" and "IQ" specifically for these reason.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by davvolun on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @05:01PM (#16433385)
I think the point is moreso, connecting correlation to causation is really, really, really, really hard, even for simple stuff. And sample size doesn't change that, it may even make it harder (see Simpson's Paradox re: 1964 U.S. Civil Rights Act). I don't know that the_watcher is arguing against college, more noting the underlying assumption and playing devil's advocate.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by ithilglin909 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:13PM (#16432050)
I would absolutely prefer to send my (hypothetical) children to college for the reasons you've stated here.

But really: are increased earnings due to anything people learn at college or because of its social value? I.e. it's been over-sold and many people will assume you're dumb/couldn't get accepted somewhere if you don't play along.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by whatyoucantsay on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:36PM (#16432751)
> *My kids will have plenty of competition for jobs

This is the downside of pursuing the same highly commoditized skills being taught to millions of other uni students.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by kimmel on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:19PM (#16432105)
The 1992 study is basically irrelevant since the job market has changed drastically. There are way more self taught computer people out making money without degrees than in 1992 as just one major factor that has changed in over two decades.

The Berkeley study is missing a lot of data and is dated as well from 1999. I searched for the most common high paying non-degree jobs and found nothing about them. Plumbers, electricians, construction contractors, certain kinds of farmers, etc... Recently on HN it was said that construction works in California were starting at $45 an hour in many places. I know plenty of people who got non-stem degrees that do not make that 10+ years out of college and working professionally in their field the whole time.

Furthermore there is the trend of people getting degrees in fields that will not yield jobs or fields that are over saturated. Take lawyers and this article from 2016 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/19/business/dealbook/an-expe... and this one from 2017 https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2017/06/28/law-schools-h... . There are plenty more articles going back more than a few years about it.

Then there is the issue of colleges and textbooks constantly increasing costs while not increasing the value of the degree itself. In fact in many instances degrees are worth less now since colleges pass students to keep that fire hose of government backed money coming in. There are numerous documentaries on youtube that go into depth of how colleges are ripping people off in many instances.

The main value of college is the ability to network with people so that finding and getting a job becomes easier. The job hunting process is broken and there are always new startups trying to fix it. In high school they pushed college as the solution to everything harder than a drug dealer slinging product. It is easy to find people who got that degree and their job and earning problems are not solved. Going to college no matter what is a dogma.

It is not clear at all that a college education is going to increase your lifetime earning. You have to pick the right field, get your debt settled quickly, live in or move to the right area and conquer the job hunting process and then you might come out ahead. I think high school students should be better educated on how the market works and there are plenty of non-degree jobs that have serious earning potential. Also the US has neglected trade schools as a job training solution while European countries have not.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by uberman on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:46PM (#16432345)
I'm sure there is nothing that will convince you at this point, however, I'll offer a final set of links.

In 2013 the "conservative" Brookings Institute seemed to agree that there is an economic advantage to a college degree.

see:

https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2013/11/12/the-eco...

and

https://www.brookings.edu/research/where-is-the-best-place-t...

If you feel like they have it wrong and that the last five years has resulted in some sort of sea change then so be it.

Good luck with your kid's high school diploma.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by whatyoucantsay on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:32PM (#16432712)
> "In 2013 the "conservative" Brookings Institute seemed to agree..."

Setting aside the core causation/correlation problem with your claims about scholastic credentials, it's absurd to call the Brookings institute conservative. It's centre left and, in US election donations, its employees give 97.6% Democrat.

https://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2011/03/03/think-tank-e...

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by exclusiv on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:49PM (#16431865)
In this case, I don't think your data is that strong. The parent could get them an entry level job in tech, conceivably one comparable with one one would obtain fresh out of college.

Separately from this specific case, remember, to pay off 200k in debt (cost of many good public schools), you need to make about 2M! If you save 20%, then you need an EXTRA 1M over not going to college just to break even. I'm not even factoring in interest that many students are getting these days. And then you have the opportunity cost of not investing the money you did make when you didn't have debt by skipping college. So when you consider these things, a 900k bump in lifetime earnings doesn't look good.

Now if you get a scholarship or if you factor in the intangibles the parent mentions then I think it's a no brainer. But strictly from a lifetime earnings standpoint it's oversold. You have to factor in the foregone earnings, the debt, the interest and the opportunity cost of not being able to save and invest money.

Personally I think it's worth it but best for most people to go to a lower tier university that won't start them off with a mountain of debt.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by uberman on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:26PM (#16432168)
You can certainly accumulate a mountain of debt and one should factor that in.

Not all degrees at all colleges make economic sense or have the same rate of return. That said, there are plenty of net present value calculations that include opportunity costs including in the links I have provided.

I want to correct a few things though.

Leaving the opportunity to take 2 years of community college and finish at a university aside, the most expensive public school in the USA (for in-state students) is the University of Pittsburgh at about $19k a year.

Your $200k debt for public education is either grossly exaggerated, is for out of state tuition and/or includes other factors such as housing and food (items that you would have had to purchase regardless of college status). In fact, the average graduation debt for those at public institutions was $25,550 not $200,000.

The opportunity cost to invest the cost of college is also unrealistic. Unless you are a Thiel Fellow, no one is going to loan/give you $200k to "play the market" as a high school graduate.

You do get an economic advantage of entering the workforce sooner than a college graduate, but that advantage lasts for about 10 years on average and by that time a college graduate typically catches the earnings of a high school graduate (cost of degree and opportunity included).

You might also be interested in this Brookings report comparing investing is stocks, bonds, or university

https://www.brookings.edu/research/where-is-the-best-place-t...

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by cableshaft on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @06:07PM (#16433784)
That $25,550 average for college graduation debt is out of date. As of 2016, that number is up to $37,172, which itself was up from $35k the previous year. It's probably up to close to $40k as of this year.

It breaks it down further in there. For combined undergraduate and graduate programs, getting an MS brings it up to $50k, Law is $140k, Medicine is $160k.

Source: https://studentloanhero.com/student-loan-debt-statistics/

And Law doesn't even pay that great if you're not at the tippy top of your class anymore. The average salary for that is at $82k a year. I'm making more than that, and my student loans (that were only $25k at their max) have been really annoying. I can't imagine being able to pay $140k of loans for a Law degree while only making $82k a year.

Source: https://www.biglawinvestor.com/bimodal-salary-distribution-c...

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by exclusiv on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @11:27PM (#16435138)
Ok yes if you attend in-state then 20k (tuition, books) is doable for a good school.

But let's say 60k in debt though, saving 10% isn't even easy for most people especially if you're in an expensive area where most the jobs are. So you'd need 600k extra. Most people only save 2.2% of their income.

> In fact, the average graduation debt for those at public institutions was $25,550 not $200,000.

The average graduation debt probably includes payments made by parents. Yes if your education is being subsidized that will change the analysis. You can't really answer the question of whether college is a good idea unless you know if there are any subsidies for a person. Also your numbers are outdated. It's 38k in 2017.

I looked at your Brookings report but it's from 2011 and factors in an average 4 year degree at only 48k. If they update it to 2018 their 15% return would crumble.

Additionally, Brookings says "On average, 18 and 19 year olds right out of high school earn about $11,600 per year, while 20 and 21 year olds with a high school degree average about $15,400 per year".

Anyone that can get entry level in tech (as the parent suggested) will be multiples of that. If you can only obtain a 11-15k yr annual salary, then yes I agree college is a good investment (if you go in-state). But if you compare it to entry level tech as the parent suggests or an electrician or other trade rather than minimum wage fresh out of high school, no I don't think it's wise for most people unless someone is helping you pay for it (scholarship, parents, company, etc.). A 2 yr or cheap online degree is probably better for most people in my opinion.

Sources:

https://www.financialsamurai.com/the-average-savings-rates-b...

https://www.debt.org/students/

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by nshelly on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:48PM (#16431857)
If a student can get into MIT that student will likely be financially well off no matter where they go, even after an upper middle-class family spends nearly $300,000 in tuition, room and board. It's the edge cases that are much harder. Try comparing an expensive private school for four years with a state school (three if they accept AP courses).

Of course there are a lot of other non-financial reasons to attend college, such as growing a circle of friends and being exposed to new ideas in a formal setting. It's unclear how to value that properly however.

Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by Z-Widwil on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:23PM (#16432637)
When you say 'run of the mill degree' are you referring to Associates, Bachelor, or higher? Additionally, do you know how the data you shared compares to individuals with technical certificates?
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by JamesBarney on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:00PM (#16432460)
The average person who graduates from college is different from.the average person who doesn't in more attributes than "degree held".
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by uberman on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:04PM (#16432492)
Read the rest of this branch of the thread including links to twins studies. If you disagree after reading that and the evidence I present then we will agree to disagree.
Re:After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of t... by JamesBarney on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:10PM (#16432528)
The Australian twins study didn't look at income. They looked "two-digit occupation" codes.

Also whether you use monozygotic or dizygotic twins matters.

See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3359051/

When just looking at monozygotic twins, ones that don't attend university actually make more money.