News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Countries with more gender equality have fewer female STE... by naasking on Monday February 19, 2018 @01:13AM (#16411077)
> Based on the myriad amount of women who can do work of a similar calibre (in medicine especially), AND the evidence that women used to be not only more welcome in programming, but absolutely DOMINANT in it: I disagree with the former, and subscribe to the latter opinion.

You would be incorrect. Programming used to be considered an offshoot of secretarial and data entry work, which is why it was once dominated by women. Then men's engagement skyrocketed while women's ambled along at a more gradual pace.

Secondly, this isn't about ability. Women are just as capable of doing this work, but there does exist an innate interest component. I recommend you read up on the people vs. things hypothesis, which has a high degree of predictive success in categorizing those who ultimately choose STEM work [1]. Those interested in working with things are driven towards pure STEM, and those interested in working with people largely avoid STEM or do STEM where they can apply those skills to work with people (think chemistry degrees to become pharmacists, math degrees to become teachers, etc.).

And lo and behold, wouldn't you know that those interested in working with things are largely men, by a significant margin, and those interested in working with people are largely women. Some of these tendencies may be socially influenced, but these preferences show up as young as grade 3!

Now there's definitely discrimination in STEM, but I haven't seen a comparative analysis that demonstrates that STEM exhibits worse rates of discrimination than other fields, such that it deserves all of this negative press. People just seem to assume that's the case because of the gender ratios and some terrible discrimination stories you've no doubt read about. I've read such stories about medicine and law, which have long since achieved gender parity.

So then empathetic people naturally conclude that the best way to stop this discrimination is by balancing the gender scales, but this whole edifice is based on very questionable premises, and the remedy consists of literally forcing women to pursue careers they're not interested in. The cure seems frankly worse than the disease.

[1] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.0018...

There are no comments on this comment yet.