Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by donarb on Sunday February 18, 2018 @05:19PM
(#16409139)
What company would invest $300M and not expect some period of exclusivity?
Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by kristofferR on Sunday February 18, 2018 @06:23PM
(#16409513)
For cell coverage in the Oslo subways the carriers simply cooperated and payed their share of the cost (based on market share).
That seems like a much simpler solution than creating a new monopolistic and rent-seeking company.
Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by gaadd33 on Sunday February 18, 2018 @09:21PM
(#16410314)
In 5 years when the market share has changed are the carriers okay with subsidizing someone else's access while they haven't recouped their sunk costs? If I start a new cell company in Oslo do I automatically get access for free since I have 0 market share?
For NYC, in theory it would have been better if the infrastructure was provided by the MTA and access to it was rented out to each carrier based on usage.
Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by chrisseaton on Sunday February 18, 2018 @06:28PM
(#16409538)
Is it a monopoly when you hire just one person to cut your lawn? Why is this any different?
Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by bob_theslob646 on Sunday February 18, 2018 @07:02PM
(#16409719)
The difference is you had a choice on hiring who you wanted to cut your lawn...
Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by chrisseaton on Sunday February 18, 2018 @07:16PM
(#16409782)
And so did the people running the NYC subway who hired this contractor...
I don't really get it. Do you think the government should never award any contracts to anyone? How do you think that will work?
Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by bob_theslob646 on Sunday February 18, 2018 @07:21PM
(#16409811)
Most cities around the United States require that the contract be renewed after a certain period of time ( usually 2 to 5 years) to prevent things like massive contracts like this from occurring because of gigantic break up clauses that will eventually cost the city and to also promote competition so that the city knows that they're getting the best price.
Re:How NYC’s subway got wireless in the tunnels
by jessriedel on Sunday February 18, 2018 @04:40PM
(#16408882)
Presumably it is intended to be monopolistic, just like a patent (which lasts 20 years).
27 years ?!?! How is this not monopolistic?