It isn’t "random sounds and words". While Joyce chose to make the surface of the book a constant stream of puns and other wordplay by drawing on a large number of languages, Finnegans Wake has a character, story, setting, etc. like any other novel. I personally find the Wake tiresome – who was the contemporary of Joyce’s who called the book something like an “electrified punning machine”? – but "Emperor’s new clothes” it definitely isn’t.
I understand the words. hoarish means hairy, and sethulose is an obvious misspelling of cellulose. Good. Lots of wordplay as you say.
But the actual sentence doesn't make any sense. That's the issue. Growing hair has nothing to do with cellulose, and humans don't make cellulose anyway. Plants make cellulose out of sugar - but why specify "cane"? Because it sounded cool to him, but not because it actually makes any sense.
You are finding "character, story, setting" only because you are ignoring any parts that don't make sense, then finding meaning in the rest. It's a form of pareidolia.
The fact that someone made pareidolia in written form? Pretty cool. But don't think there is anything there to study, other than wordplay and sounds. There isn't. And that's why it's the "Emperor’s new clothes”.
Extracting a single line out of a book that (like human communication in general) depends on the wider context of the diction, and then attacking the whole book as nonsense, is fallacious. Come on, l'arbitraire du signe has been well-known for a century now.
> You are finding "character, story, setting" only because you are ignoring any parts that don't make sense, then finding meaning in the rest. It's a form of pareidolia.
A number of commentators on the Wake reached the same agreement on the book’s character and general plot independently of each other in the years immediately following its publication.
In any event, even if the Wake were merely “inventing sounds” (which it isn’t), that still wouldn’t make it “Emperor’s new clothes”. Nonsense poetry has been an established literary genre since the mid-19th century, well before the era of modernism. That ranges from work that obeys the general syntax of the language even if certain words are nonsense, to poems that are outright written in what might as well be a foreign language unintelligible to the reader but attractive because of the words’ inherent musical quality to speakers of the poet’s language. Some of these poems, like Lewis Carroll’s "Jabberwocky" [1] or Sándor Weöres's "Kínai templom" [2] are practically part of their countries’ respective literary canons and commonly read in schools.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jabberwocky
[2] http://www.okm.gov.hu/letolt/retorika/ab/szoveg/komm/kinai.h...
Dr Seuss was also very good at poking fun of literary twits.
As best as I can tell it's just random sounds and words. It was probably fun to write, but there's no reason to try to read it.
You've never heard kids making sound just for fun? To hear the sound of their own voice? It's lots of fun to do, and even join in, but there's nothing there to actually try to study.
I read those laudatory praises people have for it, and it's very obvious they are just trying to make themselves seem important and "in the know", when actually it's just nonsense. The Emperor has no clothes. Have we learned nothing from that fable?