Reading can just mean reading word by word, symbol by symbol then putting the book on the shelf. That ends up happening a lot with material that has a lot of formulas and theorems. It could take days for some to understand just a couple of pages.
So basically I not surprised at all that you've met so many people who've read the volumes, but didn't all the subtleties.
I think reading the volumes is the next step in status show-off step after buying and putting them on the shelf.
Also, as many have pointed that MIX is just too obscure. Not knowing much about doesn't really indicate a lack of theoretical knowledge. I would personally skipped over those chapters.
I've seen several equally dense, informative CS books (such as Dick Grune's _Parsing Techniques: A Practical Guide_), but Knuth has a specific sort of cachet among xkcd-quoting geek hipsters, so people namedropping him, make a pretense of having read them all the way through, etc.
(Knuth denies this ever happened.)
I've found a suspiciously high percentage of the people who have totally! read the Art of Computer Programming are unable to answer even basic questions about MIX, by the way.