News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:26PM (#16394522)
Then apparently it is impossible to run a SaaS app connecting drivers and passengers for a ~25% cut of current prices.

That seems pretty unlikely. We need to move on from this unsupportable "ride sharing pricing is unsustainable" narrative.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by Jasper_ on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:52PM (#16394791)
The expensive part of Uber isn't the SaaS app or even the engineers. It's the overhead of running a law-avoiding lobbying business that explicitly seeks out to just do everything as evil as possible.

Hell, Uber tried being a predatory car loan business for quite some time, which you would think would be one of the easiest ways to make surefire money, but they lost on that one too: http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-subprime-auto-loans-runn...

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by TheCoelacanth on Friday February 16, 2018 @10:51PM (#16398867)
I was under the impression the the really expensive part was driver incentives to keep more drivers on the road than is economically sustainable with current levels of rider demand to allow them to grow more quickly.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:23PM (#16395141)
Even if your claim were supportable, it wouldn't explain how competitors not "seeking out to just do everything as evil as possible" have competitive prices.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by Jasper_ on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:10PM (#16396310)
There can be an argument that Uber's expensive policy-mongering is enabling the competition. Lyft doesn't have to do any lobbying, it just has to lie in its wake while Uber does everything for it pretending to be the nicer company. As long as Uber is out there wreaking regulation havoc, Lyft is happy to sit back and let Uber do that. Perhaps Lyft doesn't want Uber to die, since they're basically the ones spending money to make Lyft viable at all.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:20PM (#16396443)
Then it's very polite of Lyft to price competitively to allow Uber to stay relevant when they could easily undercut them, due to their much smaller line item for "expensive policy-mongering."

This is conspiracy-theory level evidence and rationalizing.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by zanny on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:30PM (#16395204)
Because the competitors are like comparing Sonic to Comcast. One operates in one state between two cities and has a hundred thousand customers. The other is a national monopoly that abuses over a hundred million people.

Sonic can be competitive with Comcast where it operates, but it is still a tiny blip on Comcasts radar. Uber has way, way more market volume and penetration than any one competitor, and in many places are the only game in town.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by Someone on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:12PM (#16395001)
Such a business can be sustainable, but the questions are whether it warrants Uber’s valuation and whether getting customers is worth the amount of money Uber pays for it.

Apparently some investors think the answer to both is yes. Otherwise, Uber wouldn’t get the money they get.

Other people disagree, though. I’m one of them. I think it is worthwhile to invest in getting some users to your platform, but I fear they attract way too many customers who are cost conscious, and will move to a different provider without blinking an eye.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:29PM (#16395199)
I'm responding to this question:

> what if the model of both businesses just isn't actually viable without massive injections of funds?

I don't know if Uber's valuation or investors are correct. The question is whether or not the business (or one like it) can fundamentally exist without investors pouring money into it.

By your claim, it sounds like you'd agree with me because a competitor is likely to emerge with similar or cheaper rates. I agree. But that in no way supports parent's claim that the price (or business model) may be unsustainable.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:40PM (#16394669)
I don't think I follow. There's nothing impossible about running a livery service with a cell phone application for hailing, but I don't think current prices are sustainable. It is not a business with substantial economies of sale.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:49PM (#16394759)
Well, drivers are voluntarily choosing to drive for what they're getting paid. Riders are voluntarily choosing to pay the quoted price. Uber takes a cut from the price to run the part of the business that isn't actually driving cars.

The only way the price is subsidized is if the business couldn't be run without Uber's cut covering the non-driving parts of the business, which is unlikely. They're taking ~25% (or more) on each fare. That's a huge margin for a SaaS app and administrative work.

If Uber disappeared tomorrow, it would not be that difficult for someone to build something similarly and price it the same way. In many areas, it's already happened. That suggests the price is not unsustainable.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:56PM (#16394822)
On the other hand, they're losing billions of dollars.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:18PM (#16395076)
Yep. It does cost money to expand into new geographic areas or markets (like Uber eats). That doesn't indicate that ride prices are subsidized, though.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by alonmower on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:24PM (#16396479)
As I understood it when they enter new markets (and maybe in other cases?) they sometimes end up paying out the drivers more than the rider paid. I personally remember a handful of occasions in SF when they had absurdly low rates for some period of time (like the two dollar rides when UberPool first started) where they were definitely losing money on every ride.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:57PM (#16396833)
In those cases: Sure, they must have been losing money on those rides. As far as I know, though, the norm across the board is the 25% cut (which I understand is higher at some times).
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by UncleEntity on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:36PM (#16394628)
Unsupportable for the drivers or the company?

A driver tears up their car there's a ton of people to replace them but that isn't very supportable on the individual level.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:45PM (#16394719)
If the individual driver doesn't think they're getting paid enough, that's fine. They don't have to drive for a ride-sharing company.

But it's been years now and they've got drivers, so they can't possibly be paying too far below market rate. That means the only way VCs could be "subsidizing" the price is if the remainder of the price (the cut Uber takes) is too low, which is difficult to imagine.

We already know what's actually happening--they're spending a ton of money expanding into new geographic areas and new markets (like Uber Eats). Yet that doesn't stop every Uber discussion on HN from becoming about the bubble popping on "subsidized" ride prices.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by Jasper_ on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:55PM (#16394810)
> But it's been years now and they've got drivers, so they can't possibly be paying too far below market rate.

Why do you say that? It's well-known that they've toyed in every possible way with driver rates, including showing different rates to the consumer and the driver in an attempt to hide lower-than-market-rate wages.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:20PM (#16395105)
They still have the drivers. I'm not even endorsing it--but even at worst, that means drivers are subsidizing the ride prices, not investors.

I don't think they are, though. If they were, they'd be having trouble keeping drivers working and we'd see complaints about long waits and unavailability.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by Jasper_ on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:14PM (#16396370)
There have been stories that drivers in searches of riches lease a car from Uber, which is paid off by being an Uber driver. If they leave the platform, they can't pay their lease.

Low-income "gig economy" workers might not have the mobility to leave for better jobs. Perhaps that's a privilege only certain classes of well-paying jobs have.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:21PM (#16396456)
Even if that's 100% true at face value, it has no relevance to my point.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:37PM (#16395288)
If the prices they have are too low to pay the drivers and maintain a profit then the drivers are not the party subsidizing anything.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:46PM (#16395407)
The prices are verifiably not too low to pay the drivers because they do pay the drivers at the prices they're using.

If the drivers are being paid below market rate and still driving for them, then they are the ones subsidizing.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:49PM (#16395432)
I don't think you understand. Uber loses money on every ride. The only reason they can set such low prices is they're burning through investors' money.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:17PM (#16395701)
No--the only reason they can pursue growth into new geographic areas and pursue new business models (like Uber eats) is because they're burning through investors' money. That in no way implies that their rides would not profitable if they were not spending so much on growth.

But that's basically every business focused on growth.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:33PM (#16395852)
Here is a short summary of their earlier series on the topic:

https://www.vox.com/new-money/2017/1/9/14194202/uber-lost-22...

> In an epic five-part series of blog posts, transportation industry analyst Hubert Horan lays out the case for skepticism about Uber’s hype. In his view, Uber just doesn’t have a cost advantage over its competitors the way Amazon did. Amazon saved money by getting rid of expensive retail stores and sales clerks. In contrast, an Uber ride still requires a car, a driver, and some fuel just like a conventional taxi ride. So there isn’t much room for Uber to undercut its competitors.

> “This industry has a simple cost structure,” Horan told me in January. “Labor is about 58 percent, fuel is 9 percent, and so forth.”

> Of course, this flies in the face of many customers’ experiences. It sure seems like Uber has figured out how to provide a cleaner, faster ride at a lower fare. But Horan argues that this is entirely a reflection of the subsidies provided by Uber’s investors. Uber rides aren’t actually cheaper to provide than conventional taxi rides, Horan believes, it just seems like it because Uber is taking a loss on every ride.

> An obvious objection here is that Uber’s investors are not idiots. They know perfectly well that “lose money on every ride and make it up on volume” isn’t a viable business model. And when they made their investments, they presumably had access to internal financial data that isn’t available to the rest of us. It seems very unlikely that Uber could convince investors to give it $11 billion to continue pursuing a business model whose numbers didn’t add up.

> Horan told me Uber is accepting big losses now in an effort to drive conventional taxi companies and rivals like Lyft out of business. “Their growth is predatory,” Horan argued. “They are trying to displace more efficient producers.”

The article I linked also offers an argument against this logic, but I'm not persuaded by it.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:54PM (#16396116)
Uber's financials are irrelevant to whether or not the ride sharing business model is sustainable.

The argument cannot be made without claiming the non-driving part of the business cannot be run for the 25% rake they take on every fare. Period. And I don't think anyone is willing to make that claim.

That doesn't mean Uber's a good investment, or Uber is doing it right, or Uber isn't pursuing monopolistic practices, or Uber isn't ripping off drivers, or that Uber isn't doing something sufficiently different that a competitor won't beat them--none of that matters.

All that matters is whether or not the business model is sustainable without burning through investor cash. That was the question. And if someone else beats them doing it while turning a profit, the business model is still sustainable.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:13PM (#16396358)
Well, no, the article is about Uber, specifically. If you mean where I said that neither Uber nor Lyft is sustainable, then specifically what I'm referring to is operating with such low prices that rides are money-losers, aiming to raise prices after achieving total market dominance. I do not doubt that ride-sharing is a business model that can make money if prices are high enough to make the business self-sustaining, but Uber and Lyft aren't pitching themselves as such a minor variation on the traditional livery service.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by moduspol on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:55PM (#16396809)
> then specifically what I'm referring to is operating with such low prices that rides are money-losers

This is meaningless semantics. The business is growing and spending money to expand. That does not mean each ride is not priced profitably, or that each ride does not bring in more money than is spent providing that ride. It's just a more convoluted way of saying the business--at a high level--sells rides and is not turning a profit.

They are priced at a rate that entirely covers the driving after a 25% cut. For it to not be sustainable, it'd have to be not possible to run the rest of the business on that cut, which is difficult to imagine.

Your whole argument hinges on not understanding these concepts.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Saturday February 17, 2018 @12:04AM (#16399141)
I am capable of appreciating that such a circumstance is possible, but what I have read leads me to believe that's not what's happening, and instead Uber is charging prices that do not cover their costs, with the hope of achieving monopoly. Earlier series on the subject: https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-delive...

> By contrast, in the hundred years since the first motorized taxi, there has been no evidence of significant scale economies in the urban car service industry. That explains why successful operators never expanded to other cities and why there was no natural tendency towards concentration in individual markets. Drivers, vehicles and fuel account for 85% of urban car service costs. None of these costs decline significantly as companies grow. As the P&L data above demonstrates, Uber has not discovered a magical new way to drive down unit costs.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Saturday February 17, 2018 @12:37PM (#16401683)
Also the idea of money-losing customers is not exactly unfamiliar in tech companies in the first place. Surely people on HN are familiar with this.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by dnautics on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:15PM (#16395047)
In the end the driver has to eat, so whatever deception Uber does on the driver pay side is not really sustainable if it doesn't in the end meet the driver market (I was a driver for 1.5 yrs)
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by UncleEntity on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:01PM (#16396199)
> But it's been years now and they've got drivers, so they can't possibly be paying too far below market rate.

Sure they have drivers still...a whole lot of people who are basically just cashing out the equity on their cars today to make a couple bucks on the side.